A Fun Little QB Comparison
Okay. . .after hours minutes of research, I've constructed this little comparison between a few quarterbacks from the 2006 NFL Draft.
| Games | Starts | Comp | Att | Comp % | Yards | TD | INT | Rating | Win % | |
| Quarterback A | 17 | 16 | 272 | 489 | 56.0 | 3,194 | 13 | 16 | 70.9 | .438 (7-9) |
| Quarterback B | 30 | 28 | 422 | 739 | 57.1 | 4,745 | 21 | 30 | 69.0 | .607 (17-11) |
| Quarterback C | 16 | 14 | 218 | 375 | 58.1 | 2,386 | 11 | 16 | 69.0 | .571 (8-6) |
For winning %, I counted each quarterback's starts, not every game they appeared in.
Very similar, yes? As I said, all three of these quarterbacks were selected in the 2006 NFL Draft.
Two of these quarterbacks are regarded as two of the better young players at their position in the league. The third is dismissed by many as a scrub that's lucky to be on an NFL roster.
One of these three quarterbacks won a Heisman Trophy in college. Two of them won National Championships. The other is "never going to make it in the NFL" because he went to a I-AA school and was allegedly drafted much sooner than he should have been.
The media never misses an opportunity to kiss the butt of two of these quarterbacks, and never misses an opportunity to mock or rip the other one.
I'm sure most of you have figured these out by now, but here's the answers anyway.
Quarterback A is Matt Leinart of the Arizona Cardinals. A guy that's spent his short career throwing his passes in the direction of a couple of guys named Anquan Boldin and Larry Fitzgerald.
Quarterback B is Vince Young of the Tennessee Titans. This past season, Young threw nearly twice as many interceptions as touchdown passes (9 TD/17 INT), and went a full calendar month without throwing a touchdown pass.
Quarterback C is Tarvaris Jackson. He has the best completion rate of any QB listed above, despite having what might be the worst receiving corps in the NFL this past season, and is right in between Young and Leinart in terms of winning percentage.
Now. . .can someone explain to me why Leinart and Young are considered great, young quarterbacks of the future and the Vikings should cut Tarvaris Jackson at the first available opportunity?
0 recs |
4 comments
Comments
Vince Young
by Gonzo2 on Jan 1, 2008 10:11 PM CST reply actions 0 recs
t-jack
I'm not nutty on either Young or Leinart, but I'd still take them over Jackson at this point. I think I see him do to many things that an NFL QB should almost never do, regardless of their skill level or experience. He seems to be good for a couple of horrendous throws per game that are of the "okay, let's do a jump pass" type of variety. Then there's the bad reads type of throws, etc.
As I study the NFL more, it just seems that a guy like T-Jack needed to sit down for probably at least 2 years before he was ready to be the starter. And it seems like if you are really struggling to begin with as a QB in the NFL, you usually don't magically turn it around.
by Yakuza Rich on Jan 1, 2008 10:40 PM CST reply actions 0 recs
Solid...
People just need to be patient and the team needs to get the kid some help!
by TheSportsGuru on Jan 2, 2008 7:56 AM CST reply actions 0 recs
great stats Gonzo...
I didn't see the last two drives against Denver, so I can't comment...he obviously "got it" for 5 minutes in a meaningless game...I would expect that Denver was playing the vaunted "prevent" defense that the Vikings have employed so many times over the years....
I agree with the masses that we need to upgrade at WR.....I think Rice will grow into a good #2, and Wade can become the quick hitter slot guy...if we could get a legit #1, I really think the passing game could take off...work in the TE for a change, and use the RB's out of the backfield, and this offense could be special...
I am still not sold on TJ, though....yes, he's shown a lot of improvement through the year, but I still have my reservations concerning him....
- I question his overall "intelligence" as far as reading defenses, and checking down
- I question his ability to become the "leader" that every offense needs calling the signals
- I question his "toughness"...will he continue to be injury prone, and how long will his recovery time be after each "ding"...
This team can easily go 10-6 next year, and with improved play calling that will stretch defenses, and take the pressure off the running game, we could surprise....instead of using the run to set up the pass, we need to pass to set up the run...pretty common sense when it comes to play calling....
anyway, Great site, Gonzo...keep up the good work
by lowcountry viking on Jan 2, 2008 9:00 AM CST reply actions 0 recs

by 

















