Projecting the Vikings' 53-Man Roster: Wide Receivers
Okay, back into the swing of the roster projection here. Thus far we've filled 9 roster spots out of our 53. Here's who's in so far:
QB Tarvaris Jackson
QB Gus Frerotte
QB John David Booty
HB Adrian Peterson
HB Chester Taylor
HB Maurice Hicks
FB Thomas Tapeh
FB Naufahu Tahi
FB Jeff Dugan
And yes, I did debate whether to put Dugan in the FB category or the TE category. I finally placed him with the FBs because I think that's more or less what his role is. Unless my memory is bad, I seem to remember him lining up in the backfield more frequently than as an in-line blocker, but it's entirely possible that I'm wrong there.
Now we get to a position that might actually have some intrigue involved with it, the Minnesota wide receivers. We'll start with the wide receivers. Here's a quick little riddle for everybody. What do Troy Williamson, Koren Robinson, Travis Taylor, Billy McMullen, Bethel Johnson, and Marcus Robinson have in common?
Give up? I'll accept one of two answers:
1) They were the wide receivers that the Vikings had when Brad Childress took the reins before the 2006 season.
2) None of them are drawing a paycheck from the Minnesota Vikings any more.
In fact, here's everyone that IS currently getting paychecks from the Beloved Purple at the WR position:
| Number | Name | Height | Weight | Experience | College |
| 11 | Jaymar Johnson | 6' | 175 | R | Jackson State |
| 13 | Nate Jones | 6'1" | 195 | R | Texas |
| 15 | Martin Nance | 6'3" | 210 | 1 | Miami (Ohio) |
| 16 | Brent Little | 6'0" | 185 | R | Southern Illinois |
| 18 | Sidney Rice | 6'4" | 200 | 2 | South Carolina |
| 19 | Bobby Wade | 5'10" | 185 | 6 | Arizona |
| 82 | Darius Reynaud | 5'9" | 200 | R | West Virginia |
| 84 | Aundrae Allison | 6'0" | 200 | 2 | East Carolina |
| 85 | Justin Surrency | 5'11" | 180 | 1 | Northern Iowa |
| 86 | Daniel Davis | 5'9" | 165 | R | Texas Southern |
| 87 | Bernard Berrian | 6'1" | 185 | 5 | Fresno State |
| 89 | Robert Ferguson | 6'1" | 220 | 8 | Texas A&M |
Now, the intrigue isn't so much at the top of the depth chart in this case as it is at the bottom. But, naturally, we'll start out at the top.
Obviously, the Vikings didn't bring Bernard Berrian in at the money they gave him so that he could "compete for playing time." Berrian is going to be a big part of establishing the legitimacy of the Minnesota passing game in 2008. When one takes into consideration what he was surrounded by in Chicago, it's pretty amazing that Berrian was able to compile the sort of numbers that he did in 2007 (71 catches, 951 yards, 5 TDs). Now, if teams decide they're going to try to stuff 8 or 9 guys into the proverbial "box" to attempt to slow down Adrian Peterson and Chester Taylor, it's going to be Berrian's job to make them pay for it. Hopefully Tarvaris Jackson has been working on the accuracy of his deep passes, because I've got a sneaky suspicion that #87 is going to be open a lot in 2008.
The next name on the depth chart should be equally obvious. That name is Sidney Rice, the official receiver of The Daily Norseman. Rice led the Vikings in touchdown receptions in 2007 with. . .ummm, 4. Yeah, not spectacular, but also not bad for a guy that just reached the legal drinking age a week before the season opener. Watching Rice on the field (when he's healthy), it's very hard to not be impressed with his physical skills. He's got outstanding size and leaping ability, as well as nice, soft hands. The Minnesota passing game suffered significantly when Rice wasn't on the field in 2007, and I certainly hope that he can stay healthy in 2008 so he can show us what he's truly capable of.
The third and final lock for a roster spot from this group is Bobby Wade. You have to love the effort that Wade put forward in 2007 when he led the Beloved Purple in both receptions and receiving yards, but he was also the definition of a #3 WR masquerading as a #1 option. Now, with Berrian and Rice set up on the outsides, he can play the role he's best suited to. . .that being a slot/underneath option with the ability to create yardage after the catch. As the Vikings' returning receiver from last year, you can bet that he already has a decent rapport with Tarvaris Jackson, as was evident in his two TD catches in the season finale against Denver. That will only make him a bigger asset to the offense in 2008.
This is the point where things get a little murky. This is going to depend on whether or not Brad Childress decides that he's going to keep 5 or 6 wide receivers on the roster this season.
In my little world where I have the final say, the next receiver on the depth chart is Aundrae Allison. I love Allison for his return abilities as much as I love his potential as a receiver, but I think that he should get an increased look on offense based on what he showed last year. He's got some serious speed, as we saw in his contributions to the return game in 2007, but he's also got decent hands and some shiftiness, too. He's listed at 200 pounds, which makes him about 10 pounds heavier than I thought he was, and he might end up being a bigger version of Bobby Wade. I like the guy's potential, though.
Next up would probably have to be the old graybeard, Robert Ferguson. Anyone that's followed the site knows that I really wasn't a big proponent of the Ferguson signing when it took place, and I'm still not sure how great a receiver he is. . .but, boy howdy, the guy can block downfield better than darn near anybody in the league, and that's HUGE in this offense. He was second on the Vikings last season in receptions (32, one more than Sidney Rice, who missed numerous games with injuries), but I hope we won't have to rely quite as heavily on his pass-catching skills in 2007. His blocking skills and his ability to be a sort of mentor to a relatively young receiving corps should be enough to get him a roster spot.
For now, I think I'm going to keep six receivers on board. . .though I reserve the right to "cut" one later if I feel a roster spot is better used elsewhere. (These are the decisions I have to make, people.) Fighting for that #6 spot in our scenario here is a collection of rookies, undrafted free agents, and practice squad players. When Mr. Cheer or Die was at the Vikings' mini-camp last week, he seemed to be very impressed by the pure speed of Jaymar Johnson, one of Minnesota's sixth-round selections in the 2008 Draft. From the highlights I've seen of him, I can't argue with him about Johnson's speed, but it does come with the tradeoff of being very thinly built, at least as far as I can tell. He's got an adjustment to make to the speed of the NFL game, but he's a pretty intriguing prospect.
Quick, who was the leading receiver for the University of Texas in 2007? If you said Limas Sweed, you are. . .completely and totally wrong. It was, in fact, Nate Jones, who the Vikings signed as an undrafted free agent shortly after the conclusion of the 2008 Draft. After Sweed went down with an injury, Jones stepped up and led the Longhorns in both receptions (70) and receiving yards (795) while tying for the team lead in TD receptions (5). He's got decent size, but he has his work cut out for him if he's going to fight for a spot on this roster.
As will another high-profile UDFA. . .or as high-profile as UDFAs can get, anyway. . .Darius Reynaud out of West Virginia. Reynaud was considered by many sources to be the best receiver not to be selected in the 2008 Draft. He's a short, quick receiver with some pretty good return abilities.
As for the rest of the people listed. . .I don't see any of them really having an impact or having much of a chance to make the roster. I know that I, along with frequent commenter UncleBillyBonz, have been on the Martin Nance bandwagon for a while, but that ship has either sailed or is never going to get out of port. . .I'm not sure which. (I'm Air Force, not Navy.) Justin Surrency has spent a couple of years on the practice squad, and Brent Little and Daniel Davis are pretty much just there to play the fourth quarter of the first pre-season game before getting cut.
I think that, in the end, the Vikings are going to end up being just intrigued enough with the pure speed of Jaymar Johnson that they'll keep him around on the final roster. Which would leave the wide receiver depth chart looking like this:
Starters: Bernard Berrian, Sidney Rice
Backups: Bobby Wade, Aundrae Allison, Robert Ferguson, Jaymar Johnson
Practice Squad Candidates: Nate Jones, Darius Reynaud
Buh-Bye: Brent Little, Daniel Davis, Justin Surrency, Martin Nance
What do you think, everybody? Do any of you out there have any more info on guys like Nate Jones or Darius Reynaud or anyone else that I've missed or that you think could sway the decision process one way or another? I thought about including the tight ends here, too, but after further review I think they deserve their own post.
We'll get to that post tomorrow. . .until then, enjoy the rest of your Thursday night, everybody!
0 recs |
6
comments
Read Related
Comments
If Berrian Pans Out......
Berrian, in my opinion, is a number two wide receiver. While his statistics were impressive for the high school football team the Bears assembled on offense, he drops way too many passes, and has not proven himself to be worth the type of money the Vikes tossed at him. He is very explosive, I’m just worried even with AD running the ball that T-Jack will not make the most of him.
Sid the Kid in time with be a stud wide receiver, but after missing a handful of game to injury, I think the jury is still out. He looks silky smooth, fluid, and has amazing hands, but I’m not sure he can take the bruising of the NFL. Randy Mo’ has made a living with Sid’s body type, but Sid does not have Randy Mo’s skills.
Blah i don’t even know where I’m going with this comment…basically I think the Vikings have a #2 WR in Berrian, #2B in Rice, #3 WR in Wade. Still missing the number one, even though Berrian is paid like a top 5 WR in the league.
by The Heat on May 29, 2008 11:55 PM CDT 0 recs
A corps that will be greatly underestimated...
Good analysis Gonzo.
Berrian racked up those numbers last year in our division with some of the worst quarterbacks in the league struggling just not to be sacked every time they dropped back. Throw him in a position with a markedly better quarterback [and if you want to argue that T-Jack isn’t as good as Grossman/Orton/Greise, I’m there for that] and what should be minimal coverage due to the threat of AD, and Bernard should be racking up the best numbers of his career.
Sidney Rice will continue to improve and within a couple of years we’ll be talking of how we have a #1 and #1B receiver.
This will probably Fergy’s last season with the team, but like you, I like his mentorship and downfield blocking prowess. Channel 5 did a piece on wide receivers, Rice in particular, but highlights the teamwork and selfless effort that this group is doing to get better. Both Berrian and Ferguson have taken leadership in that process. It is this effort that will make them all stand out this year.
It may take a village to raise a child, but it takes a Viking to raze a village.
by Luft Krigare on May 30, 2008 1:27 AM CDT 0 recs
2A & 2B
In the KAO offense, there isn’t a true need for a #1 receiver. Even with two #2 receivers starting, they are different enough in there skill sets (Berrian for the “deepsies” and Rice for the “catchsies”) as well as competent in there roles, to open up the 5-7 yard game (for others ironically) that this offense needs to be truly successful.
by Iceland-Viking on May 30, 2008 4:15 AM CDT 0 recs
Ferguson
I’m still not sold on Ferguson. I would have a hard time cutting him though too. If one of these UDFAs shines enough in pre-season, I could see the Vikes saying bye-bye to Fergy. I’m not sure his uber-blocking skills are enough to keep him around.
by dthompson on May 30, 2008 8:31 AM CDT 0 recs
Dead On
Berrian will catch those 8-in-the-box-killers deep and has the seniority to gently curse Tarvaris out if he doesn’t hit him. Rice is bound for glory and has the height and the leap to be the red zone threat. Wade has the moxie to make those stick-moving grabs over the middle. Allison is quite capable when any injuries strike the starters. Fergy will stop DB’s from even thinking about taking that grab at AD’s shoelaces. Jaymar will have no easy fight making the roster, but if he clicks on special teams, he can surely make it. I’ve always been on the Martin Nance bandwagon, but frankly there are no chairs left open.
by Elgar on May 30, 2008 10:11 AM CDT 0 recs
Johnson/Ferguson/Allison
Great analysis!
I agree on the six receivers you’ve got making the roster. If we’d need to cut it to five, I’m wondering if Allison might be the odd man out, though.
As to Ferguson, he’s got value for his blocking skills but I discount that to some extent. I think a more robust passing attack would do more to open up the running game, than the effect of the dropoff from having a wideout that doesn’t block as well as Ferguson on the field.
Likewise, the needs for mentoring of the young receivers could probably be met by Berrian. From what I’ve been reading, he really seems to be able and willing to take on that role.
That said though, I’d want Ferguson on the team this year. Even though Ferguson has never shown the skills to be an elite receiver in his career, I think his experience level makes him the best backup receiver for the inevitable injury situations. As a plus, he really wants to play for the Vikings and to help the team succeed.
From everything that I’ve heard of Jaymar Johnson, he’s fast, he’s quick, and he’s got hands like velcro. He’s a hard worker. His only problem is his experience level, IMO. Yeah, he’s kinda lightweight, but he’s still built more solid than Anthony Carter was.
With Johnson’s small school background, I think he’s just never been in a situation to learn the art of receiving. I think I saw one comment that everything he knows about receiving he learned from his brother. As a strength, iIt sounds like snatching the ball out of the air comes as natural to him as signing his name. With NFL caliber receiver coaches, along with what he can learn from Berrian and the rest of the Vikings receivers, he should be able to develop the other needed skills. Speed and quickness would be a lot tougher to teach than how to run routes, get separation, and get yards after the catch. From the limited info I can gather on the internet, I get a feeling that the guy could be outstanding if he’d just get the training.
Plus, as a bonus, Johnson’s a punt returner. I don’t know how many yards per return he’d get, but with those sticky hands at least he wouldn’t be dropping punts and turning the ball over right after the defense has busted their butts to get the opposing offense off the field.
For the long term potential, I hope he makes the team, but since he’s so unpolished I could understand him being cut if we can only carry five wideouts and the decisionmakers think we have a good enough shot at a superbowl run this year that they need to have as many positions as possible filled by players that can produce from day one.
As to Allison, his kick return duties could be assumed by Maurice Hicks this year and his receiving skills are unpoven at this point, IMO. He only caught eight passes all season, and one of those he fumbled away. With the lack of depth that we had at wide receiver last year, he already had every opportunity to prove himself. He wasn’t having to compete against elite receivers for playing time.
That said though, Allison’s potential and the year of experience with the Vikings should clearly earn him a spot on the roster if we carry six receivers…. and may, even if we can only carry five this year.
by Skywatcher on May 30, 2008 10:21 PM CDT 0 recs











