Farewell, Daunte
Something happened in the NFL on Thursday afternoon. People outside of the Vikings' fan base may have noticed it. . .then again, they may not have. But for those of us that have followed this team for any length of time, it no doubt elicited a reaction one way or another.
On Thursday, Daunte Culpepper announced his retirement from the National Football League. Yes, he hadn't signed with anyone since he finished last season with the Oakland Raiders. Yes, he hadn't been the same since his knee got destroyed in a game against Carolina in 2005. Yes, the thing that some people will remember about him is the way his exit from Minnesota went. . .but the thing that the more intelligent Viking fans among us will remember are the moments that #11 provided on the field rather than off of it.
Culpepper exploded onto the scene in 2000, but only after then-head coach Dennis Green exhausted every possible option at the position. Green tried to re-sign Jeff George and even attempted to bring in an aging Dan Marino before turning the reigns over to Culpepper. Prior to that, his playing experience consisted of three plays and zero pass attempts, as he was the #3 QB during the 1999 season. All Culpepper did that season was tally 40 total touchdowns (33 passing, 7 rushing) as he led the Vikings to the NFC Championship game. Yes, the Vikings got thumped in that game by the New York Giants. But in a game where everybody else had basically given up shortly after getting off the bus at the Meadowlands. . .yeah, Randy Moss, I'm looking at you here. . .#11 was the only player on the Minnesota sideline that seemed to care whether the Vikings won or lost that afternoon.
The next couple of years saw more downs than ups for Culpepper. During training camp in 2001, he was shaken. . .as was the rest of the team. . .by the deaths of Chip Myers, who was going to be the team's new offensive coordinator, and offensive lineman Korey Stringer, who Culpepper had become close with during his time in Minnesota. In a tumultous 2001 season, Culpepper blew out his knee in a game against Pittsburgh, and the Vikings went a disappointing 5-11 in the final year of the Denny Green era.
In 2002, new head coach Mike Tice implemented what came to be known as the "Randy Ratio," which basically said that a set percentage of plays needed to go to receiver Randy Moss. It was a concept that can generously be termed as a galactically stupid idea, as the Vikings offense sputtered in its attempts to meet that ratio, and the team went 6-10. However, they did manage to win their last three games of the year, and that momentum carried them into the 2003 season.
In 2003, the Vikings went 9-7 and missed out on the playoffs because the defense couldn't hold a 11-point lead over the Arizona Cardinals with two minutes left on the clock on the final weekend of the season. We won't discuss that any further here.
In 2004, Daunte Culpepper put up what was, quite frankly, the single greatest season put together by any quarterback. Ever. Yeah, that's right. . .ever. He set a record for total yardage in a season, eclipsing a record held by Dan Marino. He threw 39 touchdown passes to 11 interceptions. He led the Vikings to a first-round humiliation of the Green Bay Packers at Lambeau Field in the playoffs. And, as this article from the folks at Pro Football Reference shows, he did it with what could politely be termed as a garbage supporting cast. For crying out loud, Daunte Culpepper made Nate freaking Burleson a 1,000-yard receiver. Tell me that that alone doesn't take an amazing level of talent.
Then, in 2005, after what could nicely be termed as a rough start, Culpepper led the Vikings to yet another embarassment of the Packers, leading the Vikings back from a 17-0 halftime deficit and setting up Paul Edinger's 56-yard field goal at the gun to give the Vikings a victory. It was the last game that Culpepper would finish as a Viking, as he blew out his knee the next week against Carolina.
Now, I've been a Viking fan since 1984, so keep that qualifier in mind when I make the following statement.
During the time that I've been a fan of the Minnesota Vikings, nobody. . .absolutely, positively nobody. . .has played the quarterback position in purple and gold better than Daunte Culpepper.
Yes, you'll get people that will tell you that the only reason that Culpepper was ever any good was because he had Randy Moss to throw the ball to. Those people obviously have no idea what they're talking about. They're the same people who long for the salad days of Todd Bouman or Brad Johnson or another more vanilla option at quarterback.
(And, yes, the word "vanilla" in that sentence can probably be interpreted a number of ways. . .and, in the case of many of Culpepper's detractors, more than one interpretation could be considered a correct one.)
These same geniuses, when asked to explain why it is that Culpepper's most brilliant season as a Viking came during the year when Moss was hampered by injury and put up his lowest reception and yardage totals of his 7-year Vikings career, will generally start drooling all over themselves and be unable to give you anything even remotely resembling a coherent answer. Why? Because. . .again. . .they're idiots. DC did things that season that no other quarterback in the history of the league has ever done, and that I doubt will be matched any time soon.
I'm not ashamed to say that, as of this moment, Daunte Culpepper is my favorite all-time NFL player. I have a Culpepper jersey hanging in my closet that I haven't worn since the day he got injured. I had a DC "Fathead" that stayed on the wall of my purple and gold computer room until the combination of a closed room and the Mississippi heat made it not stick any more. During the off-season, or after particularly tough Viking losses, I still pull out my DVD copy of the 2004 playoff game against Green Bay, plug it into the DVD player, and just smile for three hours as I watch the man work.
Say what you will about his exit from Minnesota or his behavior since then. . .but I feel that I was lucky to be able to watch Daunte Culpepper quarterback the Minnesota Vikings during the time he was a Viking. The man left his heart, his soul, and his right knee on the gridiron as a member of the Vikings. He was a positive part of the Minneapolis/St. Paul community when he was a part of the team, and he's provided me with far more positive moments to remember than negative ones. The detractors, the haters, the whining crybabies. . .nobody's going to remember them. Hell, nobody knows who they are now. But everyone will remember the Daunte Culpepper era in Minnesota.
Best of luck, Daunte. There are at least some of us out here in Viking land that know that you deserve nothing less.
Comments
Daunte Culpepper
Daunte had a truely memorable season. It is a shame that his career ended so poorly due to a devastating knee injury. I would add that Joe Kapp’s brilliant season in 1969, Tommy Kramer’s one or two exceptional seasons and the many many that Fran Tarkenton gave to Viking fans rank up there as well.
by TexasViking on
Sep 8, 2008 8:57 AM CDT
reply
actions
0 recs
DC
You know ive been made fun in my group of friends for years for sticking by the fact that Daunte was one of the best qbs in the league and that he was a good qb for mn. The whole “he was only good bc he had moss” schpeel is crap because there are plenty of qb that are suppose to be could who have two talented recievers ( Palmer in Cinci and Warner in Zona) and neither one of them have put up the numbers that culpepper did. Thanks Gonzo for seeing reality and not believing BJ was a better qb than Culpepper after DC got injured. I mean look what he did the following year and where he is now.
by AD is All Day on
Sep 8, 2008 9:34 AM CDT
reply
actions
0 recs
Good video and summary. That was a fun period to be a Viking fan. Hopefully we are there again. But, whether great things or another heartache happen this season, the Vikes are my team.
Daunte made some boneheaded decisions when Childress came to town. I attribute that 50% to Tice letting the players think they were in charge of the team (OK – to letting played BE in charge of the team) and 50% to Daunte’s misunderstanding of his role on a TEAM.
I’ll admit to painful memories of seeing a look of hopelessness and defeat enter Daunte’s eyes whenever the Vikings were down by two or more TDs. He had perhaps the best physical skills of any QB ever. But – to me, he has always seemed to lack the ability to keep fighting no matter what. Compared to the greats like Tarkenton, Elway, and yes, even Favre, he always struck me as lacking that internal drive to never, ever, ever give up. He may have loved winning, but he simply didn’t hate losing enough. Of course, it wasn’t just Daunte, the whole team seemed infected at that time. When they were good, they were great. When they were bad, they quit.
In the end, I think that is why Daunte was not picked up by a team. When his knee injury took away some of his physical skills, he lacked the emotional and mental toughness to overcome.
by dkerfoot on
Sep 8, 2008 9:34 AM CDT
reply
actions
0 recs
Gettin' the Roll On
He’s had some bumps along the way, but I’ve always been a fan of Daunte and was hoping he’d do well in Oakland and Miami. There were definitely some magical times under his reign.
I’m routing hard for TJ, but I don’t necessary “believe” in him the way I did in Daunte. Maybe he’ll make me a believer tonight with some great passes and effort against GB.
GO VIKES!!!!!!!!!
by JasonAve6413 on
Sep 8, 2008 9:45 AM CDT
reply
actions
0 recs
I will always hold Pep in high regard.
I loved watching him play. He wasn’t perfect by far but he was fun to watch!
VikeGuru is a doofus!!
by Unclebillybonz on
Sep 8, 2008 12:01 PM CDT
reply
actions
0 recs
Well, I'm in the Dante hater crowd I guess...
I never thought Culpepper was particularly good. He played at a very high level one season and I certainly don’t think he has ever been a “bottom 10” type QB. He always just seemed fairly average to me. He’d make the right reads but he lacked in accuracy at times. He didn’t throw a ton of picks but basically made up for that with fumbles.
I don’t think that Moss was the “only” reason he was any good but bet your arse he was probably the biggest single reason. It is no coincidence that Moss was on two of the top three scoring offenses OF ALL TIME. Daunte would never have had elite numbers without Randy. Every other QB, including backups, that played with Moss for the Vikings had good numbers. It wasn’t just Daunte. Daunte just happened to be the starter in Moss’s prime.
I recall whenever Daunte got hurt during those spells that our backup would come in and do equally as well in his absense. I always felt like Daunte was about the 15-20th best QB in the nfl playing amongst a top 3 offense.
I will give Culpepper one piece of credit, though. His style was perfect for the Vikings vertical pass game. He could buy extra time and launch strong deep throws. I just think a lot of QB’s could have done that with our offense, and in addition, been able to work the short and intermediate throwing game where Daunte always struggled.
My point is that he was solid but fairly average. He had some major highlight reel plays but also had some real boneheaded ones too. Record for fumbles in a season, not so good.
by Sand0 on
Sep 8, 2008 12:37 PM CDT
reply
actions
0 recs
He was the greatest deep ball thrower ever.
And he made Jermaine Wiggins look like a good tight end. Jermaine Wiggins.
He should have signed with some team as a back up, theres a real good chance he would have gotten an opportunity to play because of an injury. But I am glad he didn’t sign with the packers.
by adammoney on
Sep 8, 2008 1:18 PM CDT
reply
actions
0 recs
Randall Cunningham
How about Randall Cunningham? Warren Moon? Daunte Culpepper is just not that good. He had one two great seasons out of 9. Warren Moon is a Hall of Famer. Randall Cunningham will be. Just think if Moon got to play with Moss. I liked Daunte when he was a Viking, but there were better quarterbacks.
by dicellular on
Sep 8, 2008 1:25 PM CDT
reply
actions
0 recs
Daunte's Inferno
Daunte Culpepper is a tragic hero. I have a nagging suspicion that somewhere in the darkness, some new bible is being printed with Daunte’s picture posted under Proverbs 16:18. Daunte often gave all he had, and all he had was not enough. Fate is often cruel. That new TV show about some guy who is unknowingly also his own worst enemy also rings a bell here, but I recall some old saying about beating a dead horse. Farewell Daunte. I hope you are much more successful at retirement than Brett Farve.
by Elgar on
Sep 8, 2008 2:01 PM CDT
reply
actions
0 recs
The off-hand list of QBs Randy Moss (when healthy) made look better than they actually were
Brad Johnson
Randall Cunningham
Jeff George
Daunte Culpepper
Gus Frerotte
Todd Bouman
Tom Brady
Matt Casell
No disrespect to the 04 season that was half with Moss, half not. But Randy Moss has forever forced me to backseat the importance of a good QB behind 1 or 2 receivers that force defenses into double coverage and outjump DBs. The evidence is abundantly clear throughout his career. I pray every night before bedtime that Sidney Rice will turn into that caliber of a receiver.
I have a purple #11 jersey hanging in my closet too. I spent years defending his poor decision-making because he had a beautiful deep ball and was unstoppable when he had his legs under him. I made the same claims that Minnesota wanted a more vanilla QB.
But Daunte broke my heart. That knee injury triggered a series of terrible decisions that led to last week’s retirement.
1. Deciding to burn the bridge with Childress and the Vikings (presumably because he wanted to leave Minnesota where he had disgraced himself in 2005 on Lake Minnetonka).
2. Deciding to play when he had the same injury that sidelined Jason Kubel an entire season, even when he came back in 2006 he still wasn’t the same. Jason Kubel plays baseball. All he has to do is sprint a few times and swing right. He had a hard time doing that much. Culpepper was a quarterback.
3. Becoming his own agent.
This was a disaster in the making, and we could all see it from the day of his Miami press conference. It’s sad that now that he’s healthy he can’t get a deal done. I’m hoping for Bill Belichick to pick up the phone and try him out. The Culpepper/Moss connection would be something for me to cheer for in the AFC.
by TMW on
Sep 8, 2008 2:09 PM CDT
reply
actions
0 recs
Daunte
Culpepper was a bad QB that basically had 1 great year. As the other guys said above, look at the stats for Cunningham in 1998. Their rate stats were very similar, their QB rating was basically the same, and Cunningham threw 31 TD’s in 125 fewer pass attempts. Don’t get me wrong, I firmly believe that Mike Tice is the worst coach in the history of the NFL, but Daunte was no great QB.
Baseball's only fun if you're playing it, watching it, or thinking about it.
by Eckstreem on
Sep 8, 2008 2:57 PM CDT
reply
actions
0 recs













