But I remember the argument that you’re talking about and you kept bringing up the supposed cutting off of the sentence in Favre’s quote but you never manufactured the other half of the quote, and both Packer and Vikings fans called you out on it. He did not get “busted” and I sincerely doubt that he is a “kid.” I don’t always agree with him, but I don’t think that either he or TT is an idiot. As far as the 2 t-shirts go, they’re the exact same kind of humor (just from different sides of the argument) so saying one is smart and funny and that the other is adoscelent is simply dumb. Acme is a very good site by the way, more than worth your time

But we may have to agree to disagree on that one. Rodgers is more accurate, more mobile, and now he has a stronger arm too. I’m going to assume that Rodgers is better at reading defenses too considering BF’s penchant for picks. I believe you’re talking about leadership, but I think that they’re both very good leaders so I’m calling that a push. Pocket presence Favre may have. Rodgers is a better player right now, and I think DD would agree with that, he knows best

The whole months of will he/won’t he sign with the Vikings? Well we had to deal with months of will he/won’t he retire every year for 4 years. They did NOT care about standing in Brett Favre’s shadow. That statement is downright absurd. But my problem here is that you’re taking the things I said I DON’T hate Favre for, and saying that I shouldn’t hate him for those things. So in other words I don’t really understand what we’re debating here. My true viewpoint on the whole situation? I think he should’ve stayed retired of course. Though I like your comparison to a real life situation a lot, I gotta tell you that if I was that set for life from a money standpoint like Brett is I would be looking forward to retirement. I do not love TT, but one thing I do appreciate is that through the whole Favre thing he did only what was best for the team. I don’t agree with everything he did in the situation, but I don’t want my team to be held hostage because one player has an ego bigger than Lambeau Field. I’m sorry but I’m not going to watch that video because I just can’t believe anything the guy says anymore. There’s one problem with your example. He was not traded or forced to retire. If you retired from your job, would you expect your job back once they’ve already hired someone else? Anyone who expects that is beyond arrogant-not that Brett hasn’t earned the right to be arrogant, but he was in the wrong to try that bullshit. However, your ignoring one simple fact. He is a Viking. He could have gone to almost any other team and still retired as the God of WIsconsin, but he threw that away and it was a stupid thing to do. You say he’s not a traitor, but factually he is. If he was a Packer and he is now intentionally a Viking, that makes him a traitor, no bones about it. I don’t care what the situation, there is no suitable excuse for attempting to stick it to our franchise, or for being a Viking. Jason Taylor said he would never play for the Jets because they were rivals of the Dolphins. I expect that kind of loyalty from our franchise players. I think you should read this story it’s funny and it sums up our feelings pretty well-especially because I go to Wisconsin-Whitewater.

http://sheffieldshouse.blogspot.com/2009/06/brett-favre-are-you-serious.html