Daily Norseman: An SB Nation Community

Navigation: Jump to content areas:


Pro Quality. Fan Perspective.
Around SBN: Can Tebow Say No To Anything?

Gonzo's Fearless 53-Man Roster Projection for the 2009 Minnesota Vikings, Part II

Will Vikings' seventh-round choice Jamarca Sanford (#33) be a member of Minnesota's 53-man roster?  We'll know for sure by 5 PM Central time Saturday.(AP Photo/Paul Battaglia)

Paul Battaglia - AP

Will Vikings' seventh-round choice Jamarca Sanford (#33) be a member of Minnesota's 53-man roster? We'll know for sure by 5 PM Central time Saturday.(AP Photo/Paul Battaglia)

So on Wednesday, I took a look at who I thought would stay on the Vikings' roster for Opening Day on the offensive side of the ball.  If you'll recall, I had 27 of the 53 spots on the roster reserved.

QB (3) - Brett Favre, Sage Rosenfels, John David Booty
RB (4) - Adrian Peterson, Chester Taylor, Albert Young, Naufahu Tahi
WR (6) - Bernard Berrian, Sidney Rice, Percy Harvin, Bobby Wade, Jaymar Johnson, Darius Reynaud
TE (3) - Visanthe Shiancoe, Jim Kleinsasser, Jeff Dugan
OL (8) - Bryant McKinnie, Steve Hutchinson, John Sullivan, Anthony Herrera, Phil Loadholt, Ryan Cook, Drew Radovich, Artis Hicks
Special Teams (3) - Ryan Longwell, Chris Kluwe, Cullen Loeffler

So we need 26 more names in order to fill out the roster, and unlike the offense, there's a chance that this could potentially change due to injuries, since DE Brian Robison and LB Erin Henderson were both carted off of the Metrodome field this evening.  But, assuming their injuries aren't that serious, here's who I'd go with if I were in charge of things at Winter Park.  Believe me. . .I do not envy Rick Spielman right now.

Star-divide

Defensive Line

StartersJared Allen, Pat Williams, Kevin Williams, Ray Edwards
Backups:  Fred Evans, Letroy Guion, Jimmy Kennedy, Brian Robison, Jayme Mitchell
CutOtis Grigsby, Antoine Holmes, Tremain Johnson, Martail Burnett

Kennedy is pretty much here for insurance as far as the whole StarCaps saga is concerned.  If it were to come out between now and 5 PM Central tomorrow that the trial of the Williams' brothers wouldn't affect their availability for the 2009 season, you can scratch Kennedy off the list.  He just hasn't done enough this pre-season, in my opinion, to warrant keeping him around in the event that #93 and #94 are going to be around all season.  I originally had Martail Burnett on the big roster, but he unfortunately got caught up in a bit of a numbers game.  The Vikings might be able to sneak him back onto the practice squad again, though.

Mitchell has made pretty good progress coming back from a torn ACL that ended his 2008 campaign in the pre-season, and Evans and Guion have shown themselves to be serviceable in the middle of the defensive line.  Ten defensive linemen may seem like a lot, but with the way this team likes to rotate players around, particularly at defensive tackle, it might not be such a bad idea.

Linebackers

StartersBen Leber, E.J. Henderson, Chad Greenway
BackupsHeath Farwell, Jasper Brinkley, Erin Henderson, Kenny Onatolu
CutDavid Herron

If Erin Henderson's injury is serious enough to put him on IR, then Herron makes the team.  I think he'd be a bit of a downgrade from Erin Henderson, but hey. . .injuries happen.

If you're of the mindset that the Vikings' special teams will be much improved in 2009. . .and I am. . .then this unit is probably going to be at the heart of that transformation, and that's what you're looking for when you're deciding the back half of the roster.  We know that Henderson, Leber, and Greenway are outstanding, and I don't need to drum it into your heads any further.  But we saw what losing Heath Farwell did to this team in 2008, and his presence will definitely be felt in 2009.  Jasper Brinkley has been regarded as one of the bigger steals of the draft, and his combination of size and speed make him a good candidate to be a special teams demon as well.  Henderson the Younger played on special teams last year as well, and should only get better with another season.

The guy that intrigues the heck out of me, however, is Kenny Onatolu.  Having played his college ball at the University of Nebraska-Omaha, he went undrafted by the NFL and spent two seasons with the Edmonton Eskimos of the Canadian Football League and was signed by the Vikings after the 2008 season.  If you saw the final pre-season game, you saw #55 flying all over the place and hitting everything in sight.  He might be a little raw, but I think the guy could be great on special teams for the time being and eventually develop into a pretty good outside linebacker as well.

Defensive Backs

StartersAntoine Winfield, Cedric Griffin, Tyrell Johnson, Madieu Williams
BackupsAsher Allen, Benny Sapp, Karl Paymah, Eric Frampton, Husain Abdullah, Jamarca Sanford
CutsMarcus McCauley, Marcus Walker, Colt Anderson, De'Von Hall

I know that keeping ten defensive backs might be a bit excessive, too, but there's also a lot of special teams impact to be had here as well.  Frampton was one of the team's leading special teams tacklers last year, and Abdullah is also a capable special teamer.  Paymah was brought in, at least in part, because of his special teams prowess as well, and Jamarca Sanford has too much speed and heart (in my opinion) to warrant cutting him.  Now, if the team has to flip a coin as to whether to keep an extra DB or keep a d-lineman line Martail Burnett on the roster, I think they'll probably lean towards keeping the extra lineman.  In that case, I think either Abdullah or Sanford is most likely to find themselves on the chopping block.

This also closes out the fairly disappointing Marcus McCauley era in Minnesota.  After looking promising as a rookie in 2007, the third-round pick out of Fresno State couldn't even get on the field in 2008, and has spent most of this season playing too soft in zone coverage and getting beaten on a fairly regular basis by backup wide receivers on opposing teams.  He's officially a disappointment, and it's time for the Vikings to cut their losses with him and move on, in my opinion.  Asher Allen has looked really good, and looks to be taking after current Vikings' CB Antoine Winfield when it comes to sticking his nose into the running game and mixing things up.  He could certainly have a worse role model, that's for sure.

There you have it. . .my 53-man Vikings' roster prediction for the 2009 season.  Obviously there are some unanswered questions after tonight's pre-season finale, and we'll look over those tomorrow before the final cuts come down.  Also, we're still awaiting word on the injuries to Erin Henderson and Brian Robison, and we'll pass that info along as soon as we've got it.

0 recs  |  Comment 23 comments |

Story-email Email Printer Print

Comments

Display:

The roster looks good to me, Gonzo. I’d hate to see McCauley leave though.

"He didn’t call me or anything. It was an accident, but a lot of people would have called to see how someone is doing after they got hit in the head. Especially if they had to go on the DL." — Morneau on pitcher Ron Villone after an April 2005 beaning.

by Gonzo2 on Sep 5, 2009 12:39 AM CDT reply actions   0 recs

10 DBs are way too many

I’d keep Ian Johnson, 4 RBs (28), plus the 26 you kept minus Benny Sapp.

by KC Viking on Sep 5, 2009 12:45 AM CDT reply actions   0 recs

Sapp would be the DB I'D cut

I’m still miffed at him about the stupid crap he pulled in the second Chicago game last year (even though it did lead to the awesome 99-yard TD pass to Berrian after the even more awesome goal-line stand).

I really didn’t want to keep 10 DBs, necessarily. . .but I didn’t know which one to get rid of, and I don’t think the Vikings will kick Sapp to the curb.

The Daily Norseman - The greatest Vikings' site on the Internet!

by Gonzo on Sep 5, 2009 12:50 AM CDT up reply actions   0 recs

You did it because they’re key in STs, paymah is pretty valuable on STs, but hope to never see him on the field other than that.

by koooolaid1087 on Sep 5, 2009 1:37 AM CDT via mobile up reply actions   0 recs

Onatulu

Caught my eye a couple weeks back and heading to my favorite spot to watch the game, I couldn’t help bu tthink this kid need to stay.
I mentioned on last nights blogs that ian is a shining star in hiding. We must find a way to keep both young and Johnson. Speilman needs to evaluate which one would slide through the waivers and Young might be that guy. Not cause he is the weaker of the 2 but Ian Johnson is so high profile he may be a more “glamorous” choice. Not that often happens but it may.
Johnson shows he has a nack for slipping holes and counters defensive persuit much in a wayAP does. he is not AP but has some tools that could be strengthened over time.

by CitrusFLViking on Sep 5, 2009 10:06 AM CDT up reply actions   0 recs

Cut Paymah

He gets burned on regular basis

by WVVikings on Sep 5, 2009 1:23 AM CDT reply actions   0 recs

agree with you 99% but

I think/hope they drop booty and draft a “project” in the (hopefully) 1st round (McCoy, Bradford, Tebow?)

by koooolaid1087 on Sep 5, 2009 1:43 AM CDT via mobile reply actions   0 recs

We need tj’s legs and scrambling attribute

by koooolaid1087 on Sep 5, 2009 1:45 AM CDT via mobile up reply actions   0 recs

I mostly agree Gonzo, but I agree with WVVikings. And with Onatolu, Farwell, Frampton, Hussian, and Sanford who have been very good at special teams in the past year or this preseason, don’t really need Paymah to help there too. His spot could help with decisions at other positions.

As an aside, Arizona just cut Leonard Pope. I really liked this guy coming out of Georgia where he was a decent blocker and better red zone target. Didn’t really fit into the Cardinals pass happy attack. He could also be another 6-8, long armed blocker to hang on the end of the line and I am sure would learn alot with both McKinnie and Loadholt, and IMO, definitely has more upside than Jeff Dugan, regardless of his touchdown catch tonight.

by vikingfuture8816 on Sep 5, 2009 1:44 AM CDT reply actions   0 recs

I sure hope we keep 6 wr’s I really like the talent in the younger guys

"If at first you don't succeed - Skydiving isn't for you"

by Zoxide on Sep 5, 2009 2:14 AM CDT reply actions   0 recs

I totally agree on the idea of dropping JD Booty. This guy certainly is no Thigpen, and if we wanted to put him on our practice squad I’m sure he will clear waivers. He just looks stiff out there. We need two decent QB’s after #4 and Booty isn’t one of them.

by Easy$ on Sep 5, 2009 4:45 AM CDT reply actions   0 recs

After seeing Booty’s play last night, if it get down to him. All I have to say is may gods have mercy on us. He would be a project designed to fail.

by GB Nordic on Sep 5, 2009 8:17 AM CDT up reply actions   0 recs

Yes, by all means, let JDB fulfill his destiny, to wind up an obscure ex-Trojan QB, with a funny name.

by Anthony Carter on Sep 5, 2009 9:08 AM CDT up reply actions   0 recs

Hell, if it came down to it. I’d much rather see us let Sage go, if it were between him and TJ. But the obvious choice here, IMO, is Booty to the practice squad. Then take our chances.

by Anthony Carter on Sep 5, 2009 9:09 AM CDT up reply actions   0 recs

Sage is just fine

He is back to being given 2 nd rate targets to practice and play with in pre season. He did fine with 1st team opportunities and still can check down.
T-Jax the athlete is good but he runs out of that pocket like a frightened rabbit on the hunt. When he does that he pushes himself into one option and if that option isn’t open, he fails miserably. Good D’s are still going to chew him up. T-Jax for wildcat options is fine. I don’t know why they don’t play with different sets of ttrios in the wildcat. Now you can use Jax’s legs and one reciever option ability.

by CitrusFLViking on Sep 5, 2009 10:13 AM CDT up reply actions   0 recs

That makes me chuckle...

This IS NOT directed to you specifically Citrus, because I don’t remember exactly who actually made the posts I’m referencing.

It’s just that when a similar argument was made that T-Jax was playing with 2nd or worse stingers in the 1st game where he looked bad and Sage looked GOD, that argument was roundly ridiculed by many.

I guess it all comes down to which dog you have in this fight.

Regards,

I don't suffer from insanity...I relish every moment of it!

by the Dragon on Sep 5, 2009 1:31 PM CDT up reply actions   0 recs

Drop Booty

Is John David Booty a secret project that Chilly plans to spring on the NFL? Booty has not played enough to know what he can do and when he has played, he looks lost. Cut Booty and keep Jackson and Rosenfelds.

by TexasViking on Sep 5, 2009 9:18 AM CDT up reply actions   0 recs

Anderson

You gotta look more closely at Colt Anderson. This guy’s a thumper! Plus Mayock loves the guy. If he is cut, then he’ll be right back on the practice squad.

by MTVike on Sep 5, 2009 9:13 AM CDT reply actions   0 recs

Kenny Onatolu and Ian Johnson

Theie stock went WAY up last night. What I saw was two guys who had the idea that making this team was the most important thing in the world last night. We need character and ability like that. Onatolu > Erin Henderson. Ian Johnson needs to be on this team. He just will not give up. Although, that rediculous blitz pickup by Albert Young on TJ’s TD pass is an example of what you want from a backup back. Wow that was insane. Cut Booty, no loss there as developmental 3rd string mediocre talent are a dime a dozen.

by Jepp The Viking on Sep 5, 2009 9:22 AM CDT reply actions   0 recs

Yes

I feel bad for Booty as I feel he is getting better again playing with backups. He shoe some good poise on that final drive.
This is where I wish there was a developmental league in small markets where teams can retain rights of a player, pay a small salary to help the Develop League. I thought the UFL would do this but I don’t think they are headed that way. They said they were and then jumped into large market areas- practice spelling failure UFL
We sponsored NFL Europe. Sponsor “NFL America”
A 10 team league in cities like Salt lake, Lousville, Birmingham, San Anotonio, Portland. You can bet it would go over a lot beter than the european idea. NFL support of a plan would bring in revenue and interest from current fans who will watch even if to see their teams players develop.
Oh, to be Bill Gates and start something like this.

by CitrusFLViking on Sep 5, 2009 10:39 AM CDT up reply actions   0 recs

Yeah, why are we trying to expand in Europe anyway?

Maybe they’re trying to get the NFL into the Olympics? I like the idea of having a “Farm League” instead of having an “EU League”. Besides, the NFL stands for the “National Football League”, Not the "International Football League.?

I’m going to be pissed when the Vikings lose a home game to London one of these years.

by chaosg on Sep 6, 2009 5:44 PM CDT up reply actions   0 recs

I know it won't happen...

But I really hope we cut Benny Sapp and keep a different DB. This guy can’t cover anyone, can’t tackle, and is always out of position.

If he is our first choice nickel back, the 3rd down conversion % against us will be off the charts…

"I'm gonna make you cry...I'm gonna make you cry and dip my cookie in your tears!!!"

by mutleyil on Sep 5, 2009 4:37 PM CDT reply actions   0 recs

Can't Believe I'm Saying This...

Keep only 5 backup DBs instead of 6, and keep TJack. I don’t trust TJack to be a starting QB, but he does seem to thrive as a backup QB. Plus, I think he could be used form the Wildcat. Split him out wide, send a quick lateral his way, and then give him the option to either run in a broken field, or pass it. The other team has to respect both options.

by aladdinwa on Sep 5, 2009 4:40 PM CDT reply actions   0 recs

Ian Johnson

was cut because Albert Young is a stonger asset on special teams. Johnson showed enough talent to make an NFL roster, and the Vikings were astute enough to have taken him as an undrafted prospect, even though running back is not an area of great need for them.

When you have enough talent as a whole, you put good players on the cut list. Any team has to address its vulnerabilities, and special teams has been one of those for the Vikings. If they are lucky enough to get Ian on the practice squad, I’m sure the coaches will be very pleased. Ian certainly has put enough on film in preseason to get himself noticed, and odds are he plays in the NFL somewhere.

by Elgar on Sep 6, 2009 12:55 PM CDT reply actions   0 recs

Comments For This Post Are Closed


User Tools

DN strives to be the best blog about the Minnesota Vikings on the internet, doing so with a unique blend of insight and analysis, as well as (hopefully) wit and humor. We hope you enjoy the site, and make it your home for Minnesota Vikings info!
Start posting about the Vikings »

Join SB Nation and dive into communities focused on all your favorite teams.

Comcast NFL RedZone Moments from SB Nation

Music City Miracles
Tennessee Titans Red Zone Report
Bleeding Green Nation
Comcast NFL Red Zone stat of the week - Something doesn't have to give
Niners Nation
49ers Red Zone numbers: How effective are they?

FanPosts

Community blog posts and discussion.

Recommended FanPosts

Viking_flag_small
Why Brett Favre should Decide by April 20
Avatar_small
Saints fans heckled Favre while injured
Favre_small
all you fair weather fans can go fist yourself
Viking_flag_small
Bobby McCray Nominated for Cheap Shot Artist of the Week
Vikings_-_super_nova_small
Draft Talk!

Recent FanPosts

Tommy-kramer-_small
2011- The year of the NFL Lockout- No Football or Scab Football
Small
Brett Favre = Y.A. Tittle Redux
Avatar_small
Former Vikings in the Super Bowl
Small
No one yells at manning
Small
Superbowl 44 - Who will win it?
Percy-harvin_small
Year in Memory
Images_small
Should/Could/Would the Vikings Trade Bryant McKinnie?
Avatar_small
John Randle will enter the Hall of Fame
Percy_small
Anyone interested in Favre Pro Bowl Jersey

+ New FanPost All FanPosts >

Latest NFL Headlines from SB Nation

Windy City Gridiron
Are the Bears going backwards?
Big Blue View
Eli talks Peyton, Super Bowl
Niners Nation
100 in 100: Tony Pike (29 of 100)

Head Coach

Dailynorseman_small Gonzo

Coordinators

Dodge_front_small MilCardFan

Victory__small ericj69

Childress_small Anthony21