An Open Letter to Roger Goodell
Dear Commissioner Goodell,
Let it go, man. Seriously. Just let it go before you and the National Football League embarrass yourselves any more than you already have.
You see, Mr. Goodell, the trial of Minnesota Vikings defensive tackles Pat Williams and Kevin Williams has officially been in court since Monday morning, and some facts have come to light in this case that you and the rest of the people that work in the National Football League's offices should be flat out humiliated about. Given past precedent, you probably won't be, given your propensity for thinking that you're above the law and untouchable, but just play along with me for a bit here anyway, won't you?
Yesterday, John Lombardo. . .who has the minor, menial little task of overseeing the National Football League's anti-steroid policy, testified that between 2005 and 2007, "more than six" other NFL players had tested positive for diuretics. And how many games had those "more than six" players been suspended by the National Football League for? With the way that you're pursuing Pat and Kevin Williams, one would think you were doing so because you were attempting to apply an already-established standard for such violators of the drug policy.
However, that's not the case, as those "more than six" players that had tested positive for diuretics were suspended for a grand total of ZERO games by the National Football League. In fact, according to Pro Football Talk, Dr. Lombardo testified that in 2006, when several players had tested positive for Bumetanide specifically after having taken StarCaps, the National Football League put them in something called "probable cause" testing rather than suspending them for four games. I would assume that "probable cause" testing is something along the lines of "hey, let's make sure these guys really aren't taking steroids or other performance enhancers," but if I'm wrong on that, someone can feel free to correct me.
If the league's incompetence on this matter had stopped right there, maybe the damage could be controlled on this one and you could still get away with this garbage, although the rules of basic fairness dictate that you shouldn't. However, it gets worse due to something that has long been alleged in this case. Again, according to Pro Football Talk:
But it gets even better -- or, from the league's perspective, worse. Judge Larson also has acknowledged that, as consistently alleged by the players, the NFL knew that StarCaps had been spiked with Bumetanide but ultimately told no one that StarCaps secretly contained a prescription medication that has serious potential side effects, like heat stroke, brain swelling, and cardiac arrest.
"Mr. Crouch, a toxicologist at Aegis, found Bumetanide in StarCaps and informed [Adolpho] Birch and Dr. Lombardo of the results," Judge Larson wrote. "In November 2006, Mr. Crouch volunteered to notify the FDA that StarCaps contained Bumetanide. Dr. Lombardo agreed that the FDA should be notified. Birch, however, claimed responsibility for warning the FDA. Birch never did so."...
"Birch did not inform the NFLPA that StarCaps contained Bumetanide, but did inform it that players were prohibited from providing endorsements for Balanced Health Products, the distributor of StarCaps," Judge Larson wrote. "Birch also sent a memorandum to each team's president, general manager, and head athletic train stating that players were not to endorse Balanced Health Products." But Judge Larson also pointed out that, in past situations, the league had sent specific notices to players "alerting them of products posing health risks to players."
See, at this point I would ask what exactly your reasoning was for keeping this hidden from the NFLPA, but I've decided that I really don't care about your reasoning, because no excuse that you could come up with could possibly be considered a good one, particularly after your inconsistent application of the standards has been brought to light.
Really, Mr. Goodell, did you think it would somehow be cute or funny or something if another National Football League team, whether it's the Minnesota Vikings or anybody else, would have to go through another Korey Stringer situation due to your apparent and obvious desire to scream "GOTCHA" whenever the feeling struck you? And it would obviously only be whenever the feeling struck you, because we've already established that you have no desire to apply the standards fairly and equitably. Because let me tell you something, sir. . .my team actually lost a player that had been taking diuretics because they may or may not have known the dangers of what they were ingesting. My team went through that. . .my team's players went through that. . .my team's fans went through that. I wouldn't desire for fans of any other team to go through what we did back in August of 2001.
But you, Mr. Goodell. . .your league and their doctors would have just that happen. Because you knew that there was something out there that National Football League players were taking, and that that something contained a substance that could be fatal if taken improperly or, in this case, taken without knowing one was taking it. Why? Nobody knows why. . .and, more importantly, nobody should care why. Because your failure. . .YOUR failure. . .to disclose this to the NFLPA and its players. . .is nothing short of unconscionable.
Honestly, what would you have done had Pat Williams or Kevin Williams or Will Smith (DE for the New Orleans Saints) died on the practice field or, God help you, during a televised regular season game due to the effect of bumetanide that they had unknowingly and unwittingly ingested? Because had that happened, and it had come to light that you hadn't taken the proper steps to inform the players of the NFL of this substance being in this particular supplement. . .even when they had tried to get confirmation of such things. . .their surviving family members would pretty much own the National Football League right now, and you and some of your league doctors would probably be locked up somewhere facing criminal charges. Deservedly so, I might say.
If you had any integrity at all, Lionel Hutz and the rest of your legal team would walk into that courtroom this morning and tell the judge that you were dropping the entire thing. If you had any sense of decency, that would be followed shortly thereafter by you announcing your resignation as NFL Commissioner. But since, from the looks of those things, neither of those values are a vital part of your repertoire, I suspect that you'll continue dragging this out, because I'm sure that you're still under the impression that neither you nor the NFL's doctors have done anything wrong in this case. You're just going to continue to embarrass yourselves in this matter, but hey. . .I guess that's what you guys do. You've been exposed as the hypocrites that you are. . .but don't let me stop you from humiliating yourselves further.
Sincerely,
Christopher Gates, DailyNorseman.com
Just a guy with a football blog that actually knows the difference between right and wrong.
6 recs |
30 comments
|
Comments
Sickening
That the NFL would withhold information about a supplement that could cause serious health problems. Claiming that they would report it to the FDA and then keeping it secret is just disgusting.
Someone’s head is going to roll over this mess, and I can guarantee it won’t be the Williams’.
not that shocking though
the NFL is all about the secrets and control. I bet the CIA and FBI envy the NFL’s totalitarian regime.
A Darko Fan since 2010!
by TheEvilProfessor on Mar 10, 2010 12:17 PM CST up reply actions
sorry I hit action by mistake
One power slam from Brock and Mir might be dead. He better watch his words. He'll be eating them soon.
**Slow Clap**
That…was…awesome!!
"We're used to Favre-a-palooza now. We're engulfed in Favre-a-palooza. It's not even Favre-a-palooza anymore. He's family now."
--Vikings TE Visanthe Shiancoe, on Brett Favre
Great job Gonzo!
Dead on target! Thank God nobody died on this one.
It may take a village to raise a child, but it takes a Viking to raze a village.
Good post...
I wonder what sort of responsibility the league would actually have in the death scenario you suggest. I would think none. How can they be ultimately responsible for an individual taking a legal substance that is widely available to the public regardless of what they knew and when? It seems more fitting the FDA be held accountable for not monitoring said companies ingredients and labelling practices. The league will no doubt have to look in the mirror.
That aside, I think it is best that the case proceed. The legality of the leagues policies will be decided, delivery of said policies improved and, state and federal issues resolved and avoided in the future.
agreed.
at this point, can’t more damage to the NFL/Goodell come out of continuing the court case?
Nice job, Gonzo!
I BELIEVE...
by ArizonaVikingsFan on Mar 10, 2010 1:50 PM CST up reply actions
Not the FDA's job
Starcaps fall outside of the FDA’s responsibility because it is classified as a supplement, not a food or drug. The ONLY way the FDA can interfere is if they get reports like the one the NFL failed to report, or if people start dying. It’s an unfortunate thing but true. When companies like the NFL intentionally withhold that information from the FDA, it puts more than just their own players at risk. It’s a failure to protect every day consumers like you and me as well (that’s their target audience btw).
Supplements are dangerous and I don’t take them ever. Because they are not monitored or tested by the FDA, they do not have to contain the ingredients they say and they do not have to do what the manufacturers claim.
NFL not FDA
would be held legaly accountable in this scenario. the FDA does not regulate supplementals at all, this is the law, so they are following what congress has set down for them. the NFL however knew that StarCaps contained the controlled substance, and warned no one, that is negligence. the vikings paid millions of dollers to Korey Stringers family when he died, and I don’t believe there was any evidence the team knew he was taking dangerous supplements that contributed to his death. So yea, if a player had died from taking SarCaps, the league would have been supper sued, and most definetly lost.
Will the Real Thor Please Stand Up ... ?
by the Real Thor on Mar 11, 2010 7:45 AM CST up reply actions
So...
The FDA does not regulate supplements at all, but the NFL does? The facts in the wrongful death suit filed on behalf of the Stringers proved negligence on part of the medical staff (I don’t think supplements were involved). StarCaps doesn’t contain a controlled substance. The substance in question is legal. So no, nothing you said addresses the question of liable.
Well...
I don’t think it’s the NFL’s responsibility to test all supplements but if they become aware that an unregulated supplement contains a dangerous chemical, I think it is negligent and borderline malicious to not pass that information on to it’s employees (be that the Vikings or the players in question). What they did showed a disregard for the safety of the athletes involved, seemingly to make an example out of whoever got caught next.
me likey
great post Gonzo!!
What cracks me up the most about all of this is the fans of other teams bitching and moaning and yelling and crying that the Vikings are “cheaters”. That’s all the Williams boys are… cheaters. Yet all of the grimey, sleazy tactics by the NFL gets totally pushed aside by these fans. If this was all happening to, say, Clay Matthews and Ryan Pickett I’d like to think that after reading everything that has gone down in this case, I would be a reasonable enough person to say, “Yeah… the NFL botched this one up pretty bad… sorry Pack fans.” Separationism is so strong in the football world it’s laughable. You’d think in such an overwhelmingly one-sided case like this, fans of all teams would be able to come together and say, “What the hell is going on in the NFL FO???”
It’s pretty sad that hatred, ignorance, and naivity will never allow that.
If you can't laugh at yourself... Who can you laugh at?
The Packers, that’s who.
-- The almighty Manimal
Nice Gonzo!
The more the facts come to light, the more I feel proud to have the Williams’es on our team. These guys have stood and faced the doubters and never backed down. Every fan that called these guys cheaters should be ashamed of themselves.
"Skol pa fiskande"
Get the word out
Gonzo, If you don’t mind I’m going to post link to this story in every other Vikings forum I’m part of. I hope some of the big sports sites pick this article up like they have some of your others. This clearly articulates to all those who think Pat and Kevin are cheaters taking steroids that the real point is that the NFL could have caused them serious harm. Losing one guy was one too many. Never again.
Go ahead
And make sure to include links back. (-:
The Daily Norseman - The greatest Vikings' site on the Internet!
by Christopher Gates on Mar 10, 2010 7:01 PM CST up reply actions
mr. gates, mr. gates, mis-ta gates....
nice fucking job. honestly – as a new Vikes fan this year – wasn’t exactly knowledgeable on this topic. NOW – i am. may i repost your open letter on my blog, PASSION = TRUTH? i was heavy PR guy for the Vikes this season….. ;)
Again, not a problem
Just link it back. (-:
The Daily Norseman - The greatest Vikings' site on the Internet!
by Christopher Gates on Mar 10, 2010 8:31 PM CST up reply actions
Well stated Gonzo!
This whole thing needed some clear perspective and this certainly clarifies that the NFL was playing their own little control game at the expense of risking the lives of NFL players. Someone needs to be held accountable for that, and the buck stops at Goodell’s desk.
Ah, ah,
We come from the land of the ice and snow,
From the midnight sun where the hot springs blow.
The hammer of the gods will drive our ships to new lands,
To fight the horde, singing and crying: Valhalla, I am coming!
SKOL!
rather that just drop the case...
…can willams’ or better yet nflpa countersue?? that would really be what goodell & co deserves
"the following statement is true:
the preceding statement was false" - george carlin
You just blew the doors off the freaking house. OWNED.
"He didn’t call me or anything. It was an accident, but a lot of people would have called to see how someone is doing after they got hit in the head. Especially if they had to go on the DL." — Morneau on pitcher Ron Villone after an April 2005 beaning.
Bravo..Well Said
Kinda what I have been saying for the last couple years, only you said it more better than I could have. Can we git rid of badall now?
Great post
I just wanted to add one more thing from a Saints perspective. I think a lot of people forget that Deuce McAllister got approval from the NFL to use Starcaps. He did everything right. He contacted the NFL’s testing representative (although he said it took several attempts to finally get someone to talk to him), got them to test the stuff, and they said he could take it. The problem came when the NFL tested it a 2nd time, found the banned substance, and neglected to tell anyone about it.
These kinds of actions on the part of the NFL are simply unconscionable. The NFL acted with complete disregard to player safety and tried to punish players for the leagues mistakes. McAllister and Charles Grant are no longer with the Saints, but we will still be watching this case closely in hopes of getting some tiny bit of leverage in preventing the suspension of Will Smith. Best of luck to Kevin and Pat Williams in fighting this unjust punishment.
"I want to hand this trophy to the MVP of the Super Bowl -- and the MVP of the entire league.''
-- Saints coach Sean Payton, handing the Vince Lombardi Trophy to Drew Brees after Super Bowl 44.
Excellent post!
None of the players involved in this should have ever had to deal with this crap. Goodell and most of the owners are completed blinded to their own delusional megalomania. Their handling of this matter has been disgraceful. What makes it worse is the members of the media who obediently cast these players in a negative light from the onset. Most articles I saw from the Associated Press and others had headlines like “NFL Players Suspended for Violating League Anti-Doping Rules.” It’s no wonder so many people allowed themselves to be misinformed about this and ignorantly assumed these players were guilty of using steroids. Don’t even get me started about the whole “the league warned players to not endorse Balanced Health Products.” Warning to not endorse as opposed to warning to not ingest are two totally different things! To hell with Goodell!
"As soon as Tony (Dungy) said we had no chance, I knew we had 'em right where we wanted 'em"--Coach Sean Payton right after Super Bowl XLIV with the Lombardi Trophy firmly in hand. WHO DAT!!
What a waste of time.
Hey Goodell how bout using your energy on a new CBA!
One power slam from Brock and Mir might be dead. He better watch his words. He'll be eating them soon.
Who's the criminal?
Birch has lied on the stand (perjury). Birch told the NFL doctor that he would report the illegal drug to the FDA which he didn’t (negligence). Birch has done criminal acts over and over and is the one who needs suspended or fired. Get off your butt Goodell and do some house cleaning it’s the only way to save face after the Williams win this trial.
The NFL Commissioner Has No Shame, Also Has No Honor!
Being a retired U.S. Army Platoon Sergeant (E-7), that gave 27 years of service to defending the Constitution of the United States, I fully understand the motto “Duty, Honor, Country”!
The NFL Commissioner, has a duty to the football players, to inform them of any medicine or medical procedure that had the potential to cause harm or death to the players. The NFL Commissioner failed in his duties! The NFL Commissioner is person to be trusted, to relay important information to the NFL Players.
The NFL Commissioner, has the responsibility of being honorable to the NFL Players, and deal with them fairly and openly in all regards to situations that effect the NFL Players (on and off the field). The NFL Commissioner has No Honor, and as such, any thing the NFL Commissioner says is a lie!
The Commissioner has betrayed the trust of the millions of NFL fans, as well as the NFL players, and has seriously harmed this Country’s trust in the NFL being honest and forthcoming with all important information.
The Commisoner and his staff, should all resign..
Once you have lost your honor, it can never be regained…. from then on you are branded a Traitor, and a Liar, to everyone you meet!
~Parnelli
U.S. Army, Retired
1968-1995
Everyone we meet in life give us happiness, some by their arrival, others by their departure!

by 


















