Top 5 Worst Calls in Vikings History
In the aftermath of Joe Webb’s blatant facemask in last week’s game against Detroit that wasn’t flagged, it got me thinking about some of the other blatantly missed calls against the Vikings over the years. We complain a lot about bad calls, and it seems like the Vikings get more than their fair share of them. So, after reflecting, and doing a little internet sleuthing, here are what I would call your top 5 Worst Calls in Viking’s history.
#5. Week 8, 2006 Vikings vs Patriots. In the 3rd quarter Brad Johnson connects with TE Jermaine Wiggins for a first down inside the Patriot 35-yard line. On the catch, Wiggins has full possession, takes three full steps, and turns to head down field. As Wiggins is going down, the ball is stripped by the defense and rolls out of bounds. The correct call SHOULD have been first down at the spot where the ball rolled out of bounds. However, in the fantasy land where some NFL officials reside, the pass is ruled incomplete. Minnesota challenges, yet Referee Larry Nemmers upholds the original call. Terrible, terrible call.
#4. Week 14, 2002 Vikings vs Packers in Lambeau. LOTS of bad calls here. Here’s a short list:
-Kleinsasser *tackled* in the 4th quarter on a 3rd down pass, but no pass interference flag was thrown
-Packers called for illegal holding during a punt return, but after conference, the official picked up the flag and ruled no foul. Even the announcers were befuddled on this one.
-Questionable pass intereference call on Corey Chavous that negated an interception during the Packers game winning drive.
-With 11 seconds left, Culpepper connects to Walsh in the middle of the field with no one around. Walsh kneels down to end the play, and a Packer came in late to “tackle” him. He should have been ruled down and not “hit”.
-NFL Acknowledged at least 9 officiating mistakes in the game.
#3. Week 7, 2010 Vikings vs Packers in Lambeau. Visanthe Shiancoe’s TD catch was ruled incomplete, challenged and ruling on the field was upheld. Head of officiated privately admitted to Childress after the game it was a bad call.
#2. 2009 NFC Championship game. Bobby McCray’s low shot on Favre should have been a roughing the passer penalty. Result? No call. Mike Pereira admits later that it was a mistake by the officials and there should have been an illegal hit on the QB, thus nullifying one of Favre’s interceptions. The flag would have setup the Vikings in the redzone.
#1. December 12th, 1975. Vikings vs Cowboys in a divisional playoff game. The Play? Known as “The Hail Mary”. With 1:51 left in the game, Fran Tarkenton led the offense to a touchdown to go ahead 14-10. Dallas then reached the 50 yardline, but with only 36 seconds left, Staubach lined up once again in shotgun formation. He took the snap, pump-faked left, then turned to his right and fired the ball deep downfield to WR Drew Pearson. As the ball came down, Pearson pushed off of CB Nate Wright and caught the pass, trapping it against his hip at the 5-yard line. Drew Pearson later admitted to former Viking RB Chuck Foreman (who played in the game) that he did indeed intentionally commit offensive pass interference against Nate Wright. No flag was thrown.
This FanPost was created by a registered user of The Daily Norseman, and does not necessarily reflect the views of the staff of the site. However, since this is a community, that view is no less important.
18 comments
|
0 recs |
Do you like this story?
Comments
Uh
You forgot the Andrew Quarless touchdown in the game at Lambeau last year: It was a horrid call. Unfortunatly [for you guys], Chilly didn’t challenge it, but that call right there probably changed the way the NFL looked at touchdowns, and was a catalyst for the rule change this year where every scoring play is reviewed.
13-0
MattFlynn4StartingQB
Couldn't decide there
There were several bad calls in the game. I went with the Shiancoe call, but you’re right, the Quarless call was equally bad.
SKOL Vikings!
There's so much money in gambling on football...
…that I have a hard time believing that some of these calls are/were innocent mistakes. I can understand the missed call when the play is live, but I just can’t believe some of the bad decisions made after the “go under the hood.”
Anyway, I think my #2 is different than yours but from the same game. It was the pass interference call on Lieber that sealed the Vikings’ fate with a Saints field goal. The interference was inadvertent, but more to the point, the ball wasn’t anywhere close to the receiver.
"Man invented language to satisfy his deep need to complain." - Lily Tomlin
Lots of bad calls in that one too
I went with the call that was admitted by the NFL as being wrong. But yeah, that Lieber call was a bad one too. LOTS of bad calls in that game. Ugh!
SKOL Vikings!
take a look at this video
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=xsZEELu953c&feature=related
"Never take your eyes off of your opponent…even when you bow."
by Vikant on Dec 13, 2011 11:07 PM CST up reply actions 1 recs
Awesome video. Thanks.
I didn’t know that about the foot tripping thing. Truth is that’s a horsesh*t rule. However, it sounds like that was the right call on the tripping part.
However, if the ref was looking at the receivers feet down on the field, he was not looking at the ball in the air. No way was that ball catchable. No way. The whole “amazing athlete” argument doesn’t hold up for a TE who looks fairly planted to the ground. The arc of the ball they showed in the video was well past the receiver. The receiver was backpedalling. There is no way he gets turnaround and leaps 3 feet into the air to catch that ball. It was a horrible, horrible call that handed the Saints the win. The Vikings D had stonewalled the Saints O most of that game. It was a horrible call made infinitely worse because it took the game away from the players and gave it to the refs. Horrible call. #2 of all time.
"Man invented language to satisfy his deep need to complain." - Lily Tomlin
I’m not one to normally blame losses on the zebras. I’m really not. That 2009 NFC Championship game, however, was just absolutely ridiculous.
There was a point (well before the bullshit Lieber call in OT) that I just threw my hands up and said “whelp… the NFL wants the Saints in the ‘big game’…”
Even with an inexcusable amount of turnovers on our part (6, if I recall), and what should have been an immediately firable offense for Childress with a ‘12 Men on the Field’ penalty near the end of regulation, we still managed to get to OT. Normally teams get completely torn up with those kinds of mistakes- especially against a team of the 2009 NO Saints caliber.
So close…
Argh… shouldn’t have read this first thing in the morning. :(
by Odin'sDrunkenSon on Dec 14, 2011 8:25 AM CST reply actions
we all feel your pain
That’s why 2009 was so much worse than 1998 to me. the 2009 vikes were the best team in the nfl that year and would have easily beat the colts. the 98 vikes would have lost to the broncos in the super bowl anyway.
"At this point, what we got to lose, right? So we might as well throw caution to the wind and hit people in the face."
--Vikings DE Jared Allen
Sorry...
Didn’t mean to bum you out with the post. But I still couldn’t get over the facemask non-call, and felt compelled to drag up our past misery. I was hoping it would make me feel better about it…knowing there were worse non-calls in our history, but somehow it just made it worse.
SKOL Vikings!
...i come in peace...
Speaking of bad calls, have you guys noticed an increase in bad calls against (of for) the Vikes this year, as compared to years past?
Over at CSC, we’re noticing an extraordinary number of bad calls, mostly ones that harm us, but occasionally ones that help.
All in all, officiating seems to have gotten worse around the NFL.
Do you guys find this to be true as well?
Definitely
The NFL has cameras all OVER the field, and the TV viewing audience (not to mention most fans live at the games with the jumbo-tron) see everything. I’d be surprised if the refs get even 75% of the calls correct. It’s probably more like 66%. The fact that you can’t challenge or review penalties is beyond stupid.
SKOL Vikings!
It's way past time for the NFL to hire and train full-time officials.
NFL owners seem to be open to any reasonable change that can improve officiating and better enable them to get it right (unlike MLB). Why do they stubbornly continue to put part-time 50-60 year old men on their officiating crews?
I've got Sunday Ticket and like to gamble and play fantasy football so I watch as many different games as I can and the officiating appears to be getting worse every year.
Bad officiating is a league wide issue and it’s hard to watch a complete game without seeing multiple missed calls that are fairly blatant. One ref that stands out as being particularly bad is Jeff Tripplette. If you see this guy reffing your game, expect missed calls, incorrect calls on challenges, and a good chance he’ll actually forget or not even know what the rules are. The NFL needs full-time officials because the game’s integrity is starting to suffer from all of these bad calls.
by CanadianViking on Dec 14, 2011 5:38 PM CST up reply actions
thanks, all three of you guys, for confirming what we thought.
you’d think with the Billions of dollars in revenue, they could split a tiny % of that for FT refs… including one on the bench for each game, in case one gets injured.
It happened to us in our last game. And they refed with one less official.
What about the PI call at the end of the 2009 NFC championship?
The one where Leber interfered with a receiver who came no closer than 5 yards away from him?
That hurt.
Really. My heart felt it. 40 years of misery in a single, short post.
Let’s not do this again.
Ah, ah,
We come from the land of the ice and snow,
From the midnight sun where the hot springs blow.
The hammer of the gods will drive our ships to new lands,
To fight the horde, singing and crying: Valhalla, I am coming!
SKOL!

by 
























