White Earth Ojibwa Offer Interesting Solution To Vikings' Stadium Crisis
The stadium hearings are still going on at the State Capitol, but there was a very, very interesting solution presented a little bit ago from a very unlikely source. (I thought I might have misheard it, but the folks at the Minnesota Vikings Fan Page confirmed that I didn't mishear it at all.)
A lot of folks from the powerful Indian gaming lobby in Minnesota have testified today, and almost all of them spoke about how it would hurt them, how it would violate their exclusivity, and the other sort of stuff that you would expect. Then a member from the White Earth Band of Ojibwa got a chance to testify, and presented a solution rather than a complaint.
Their solution?
The White Earth Nation would build a casino at the Arden Hills location and would fund the public portion of the stadium.
Go ahead. Read that again.
This was completely unexpected, and I'm not sure how seriously it will be taken. . .heck, if I'm Zygi Wilf, I'm on the phone with the tribal leaders right now. . .but I fail to see a problem with this. It doesn't put any new taxes out there on anybody, it preserves the exclusivity of the Indian gaming lobby and, most importantly, gets the stadium built with no worries about the team moving. The White Earth Nation operates the Shooting Star Casino in Mahnomen, so they clearly have experience with this sort of thing.
Now, I'm sure it will also be met with what I, personally, have termed the "WON'T SOMEBODY PLEASE THINK OF THE CHILDREN" defense, how gambling takes advantage of addicts and things of that nature. Yes, people get addicted to gambling. I realize that. People also get addicted to alcohol, but we still have bars and liquor stores. People get addicted to fast food, too, but I don't hear anyone clamoring to shut down all of the McDonald's and Wendy's franchises in the Twin Cities, either.
You can get more details about the proposal right here.
86 comments
|
0 recs |
Do you like this story?
Comments
Agree
If this doesn’t work, can’t blame the Vikings for moving. I would help them pack.
by NYVIKINGS65 on Dec 8, 2011 12:38 PM CST via mobile up reply actions
I like it...
But I am not sure that Zygi Wilf will. as far as I understand it the whole point, from Wilf’s point of view, of the Arden Hills location is so that he can build up all the surrounding land and turn it into his own hotel, mall and parking lot wonderland. I am not sure he would want such a large influence on that from a third party.
it's a huge space
They should be able to work it out, and a casino would make his own plans more valuable.
by amiller92 on Dec 6, 2011 6:18 PM CST via iPhone app up reply actions
They aren't even using all of the Arden Hills space
Zygi’s got lots of room to develop that land. This would barely make a dent in it.
Plus with all the Metrodome stuff he doesn't want...
I’d bet he’d take a small hit to his grand master Arden Hills plan to actually still keep his Arden Hills plan.
Really?
Why would he not like it?
Another huge draw to an otherwise nothing location that will help fill the hotels, mall and restaurants. Hmmmm, seems like more profit to me.
Maybe i'm being a pessimistic Vikings fan
…but as Murphy’s law pertains…if it’s good good to be true, it probably is.
by anewdawn#7 on Dec 6, 2011 6:28 PM CST via mobile reply actions
I like the idea, but how about one change
How about the casino buys out the Star Tribune lots and the metrodome space? That way, the Vikings can play in the Dome for the next 3 years while construction of the Arden Hills location is erected(haha….erected) and then they can Demo the Dome once construction is complete and start on a DOWNtown casino.
I bring this up because I don’t think the Vikings are willing to build on top of the Dome site because they refuse to use TCF or anywhere else for even 1 year. They would lose way too much $$ in those years.
White Horn Gold Pants
The problem i've been reading
Is that other tribes control (and invested alot of politicalthat monies into) the exclusivity of metro gaming and wouldn’t exactly take kindly to the White Earth staking claim whether it be downtown or in Arden Hills.
by anewdawn#7 on Dec 6, 2011 7:23 PM CST via mobile up reply actions
and what about cash flow
During the delay to build the casino? And why not just put it at Block E?
Arden Hills makes more sense than your plan to me.
by amiller92 on Dec 6, 2011 8:00 PM CST via iPhone app up reply actions
Why would the casino have to buy the Strib and Metronome space?
Why wouldn’t the Vikes and the metro sports commision just extend the existing lease, or sign a new 3 year lease?
I suppose the commission could refuse to do a new lease unless the new stadium is in Minneapolis. But they could also refuse to sell the Metronome to the casino for the same reason.
Isn't then NFL's sole reason for not having a team anywhere remotely near Las Vegas
Is to not link the NFL and gambling? I like this plan and the opportunity it gives the Vikings, but I see the NFL having an issue with this…
The NFL stays away from Vegas because
you can bet on the NFL in Vegas. That would not be the case in Arden Hills.
Your fantasy football expert since Jerry Rice's rookie year.
If that's the case then Hell Yes. Build us a stadium.
I was just stating why I was being a cautious optimist. Afraid to be hurt by the NFL vetoing that one. If this works Zygi gets to have his cake and eat it too, and you know, we get to keep our beloved Vikes. But does this mean we need to toss the game whenever the Redskins come to town? Joking! Don’t hurt me! Lol
and chiefs
… but that made me laugh out loud
when asked by Dan Patrick if his name alluded to not making quick decisions in the pocket, Ponder calmly replied "As crazy as it sounds, my mom's maiden name is actually Superbowlwinner. All one word"
No that means
we are obligated to kick those retrogade em-effers arse royally.
For the honor of the tribes, of course.
Hmm, possibly.
Las Vegas does not have major-league sports, although the metropolitan population is as large or larger than many cities that have them. The two main reasons are concern about legal sports betting and competition for the entertainment dollar.
I don’t think it’s so much an issue with “gambling”, which can be done anywhere, but legal sports betting that’s the issue. It’s actually silly if you think about it. Anyone can go online and sports bet on a Vegas site. Anyone can make a phone call to Vegas and make their bets that way.
As far as the competition for the entertainment $$, its the biggest reason they don’t have a team. It’s a tourism town. Not saying ONLY gamblers live in Vegas because that would be ridiculous, but there’s too much going on already to have the NFL compete with all the casinos. If the NFL/Vikings are willing to take $$ from scratch tickets and pull-tabs, then why not a damn casino?
White Horn Gold Pants
aren't both of those
Technically illegal?
by amiller92 on Dec 6, 2011 8:01 PM CST via iPhone app up reply actions
They aren't worried about average joe's betting on the team....
Anyone can go online and sports bet on a Vegas site. Anyone can make a phone call to Vegas and make their bets that way.
The concern is for those involved with the franchise that could actually influence the outcome of a game.
when econ dumped.
nfl lessened it restrictions on gambling and being assc. with a team. but less than a decade ago the three brothers who inherited the steelers also owned atlantic city casinos so one brother dumped his casino shares to buy the other two out of the football team but now there are nfl scratch offs etc.
Very interesting.
Makes me proud of my Ojibwe blood. :)
I hope this idea is at least considered.
"I wanted to do it because it's fun, it's fun to do bad things and drive into a car."
by PurplePeopleEaters on Dec 6, 2011 6:34 PM CST reply actions
native power
ojibwe pumps through my veins too.
Let's do it.
Might as well! Sounds a lot better than some of the ideas.
"Like I said, I don’t think anybody on this team knows what schism is, let alone could use it in a sentence. I thought it was an STD when I first heard it. And I was like whoa, we preach abstinence around these parts." - Jared Allen
YES.
YES. DO IT. DO IT!!!
Man, I did NOT see that one coming- but hell to the yeah to these guys!!!
Dear Offensive Line... (follow Game Threads for the rest).
Follow @KJSegall
This seems too good.
Wilf may think he’s giving up too much control of the team and not agree.
They won't own the stadium,,,,but!
but there could be stipulations on whether or not Wilff can build hotels and such…I could be wrong about that,
but I would imagine the Casino owners would want control over hotels, and maybe a few other things!
This might be the best news of my day
Arden Hills has long since been my favorite site,
I hope this gets done.
I guess now the state would only be able to say ‘we can’t fund gambling’ instead of ‘we can’t fund the stadium’
Minnesota politics make my head hurt
when asked by Dan Patrick if his name alluded to not making quick decisions in the pocket, Ponder calmly replied "As crazy as it sounds, my mom's maiden name is actually Superbowlwinner. All one word"
Wait, so I'm confused...
Does this mean that the Arden Hills location will have both the stadium AND the casino? I guess I don’t know how big the area is, but doesn’t that seem to be limiting Wilf’s “other” investments and overall limit what the Vikings can do or even parking?
White Horn Gold Pants
it's huge
Like 400+ acres of memory serves. Tons of space.
by amiller92 on Dec 6, 2011 8:03 PM CST via iPhone app up reply actions
or 2392
Acres according to wiki.
by amiller92 on Dec 6, 2011 8:04 PM CST via iPhone app up reply actions
lol that would def fit into the 400+ category
by Lunchpail on Dec 6, 2011 10:38 PM CST via mobile up reply actions
Well
That’s the whole arsenal. Maybe I got the 400 number from just what they are planning to develop for the stadium?
400 even seems like a lot for the actual stadium
But I guess depending on how far out they go for like the concourse and all, 400 would be pretty close to the stadium.
White Horn Gold Pants
Has to be more than just the stadium
Dome sits on 25 acres I think.
400 acres
I believe is how much land Favre owns in Hattiesburg. :p
by Odin'sDrunkenSon on Dec 7, 2011 8:51 AM CST up reply actions
on the left
Side of his driveway
by Lunchpail on Dec 7, 2011 12:34 PM CST via mobile up reply actions
Seems that way
The Arden Hills Superfund site itself is pretty large at close to 2400 acres. I think the stadium is only projected to be around 400. There should be plenty of space for both the casino and what ever development plans Zygi might have, in theory anyway.
by Amrius on Dec 6, 2011 8:15 PM CST via mobile up reply actions
Well, this is interesting..
Minneapolis just agreed to contribute 300 million for the stadium.
Honestly, at this point, I could care less where it gets built. Just build the damn thing. All this political intruigue between cities has gotten old fast.
They surely have heard about this Indian gaming solution.
And now are worried about looking like big, dumb-ass dorks!
Similar proposals
Have been floated before and gone nowhere. So I wouldn’t bet money on it happening this time, even if it makes a whole lot of sense.
I like the White Earth band casino solution.
If you don’t want to pay for a portion of the Vikings new stadium, don’t gamble.
If you don’t want to pay for a portion of the Vikings stadium, but gamble anyway, well, that is your problem.
by Midnight Rambler on Dec 6, 2011 8:16 PM CST reply actions
Maybe we can convince all the anti-stadium blah blah blah people to try to "take" all the stadium $$ from the casino
see how tha works out for them.
White Horn Gold Pants
Cautiously optimisic... but still if it works...

Even if it just kicks Minneapolis into gear to actually work at something.
That'd be so rich.
Don’t want to pony up public funds but expect public control? Go fly a kite. We’ve got this.
Pretty much, yeah
“Let Zygi pay for his own stadium!”
“Okay, and Zygi is going to keep all the money, too.”
“ZYGI!? WHY U NO SHARE MONIES!?”
SBNation Minnesota - For the greatest sports fans in the world.
The Daily Norseman - The greatest Vikings' site on the Internet!
"Don't do anything by half. If you love someone, love them with all your soul. When you go to work, work your ass off. When you hate someone, hate them until it hurts." - Henry Rollins
Follow @DailyNorsemanSB
Follow @SBNMinnesota
by Christopher Gates on Dec 6, 2011 9:17 PM CST up reply actions
Woo hoo!!
Get this thing done!! Forget the politics, lets gamble! Makes my indian blood(cherokee) pump some purple kind of proud!!!
by natedawg2133 on Dec 6, 2011 9:03 PM CST via mobile reply actions
Pardon my French
but in this case, fuck the children. Build the casino. Build the stadium.
Now, if you’ll excuse me, I’ll be over on Twitter watching the “Pujols to the Marlins” unfold while playing the most depressing music I can find.
"Go hard. I mean, like relentless. I want a bunch of coaches that coach like their hair’s on fire, and I want a football team that goes for four to six seconds (per play) with relentless effort." OSU Coach Urban Meyer.
by Ted Glover on Dec 6, 2011 9:36 PM CST reply actions 1 recs
I don't know if anyone told people but Children are not allowed in casinos lol.
This would HELP the children. It would generate jobs for there parents. Kids will do fine, it isn’t a god damned Casino’s fault, GTA’s fault, Marilyn Manson’s fault or any other avenues fault other than usually it is the parent’s fault and even with the best parents in the world, sometimes kids make stupid ass choices that fuck them for life. So I agree, Fuck the children. Can we get a Fuck the Children petition going if people want to bitch about it?
IF YOU THINK REEM SHOULD BE RATED ANY HIGHER THAN AROUND THE #5 HEAVYWEIGHT (AND THAT IS STRETCHING IT) THEN YOU ARE A FLIPPIN MORON, PLAIN AND SIMPLE.
by Edgecrusher71 on Dec 7, 2011 3:51 PM CST up reply actions
I had a feeling something would happen soon
An NFL stadium is a HUGE money maker, just had to take a group of people willing to look past the typical rhetoric to see it and be willing to make a down payment
you play to WIN THE GAME, that's the great thing about sports
Wow...
This is a great friggin’ idea.
by Bjorno on Dec 6, 2011 10:11 PM CST via mobile reply actions
@ Christian
I think so but I don’t think they would tell anyone else if they did either. Their are other areas to go besides Los Angeles. 2 quick ones come to mind San Antonio( Jerry JOnes would squashe that though) Then you have Toronto, Canada.
I wonder really here for a second. Does Ziggy no disrespect to him but he has a serious vision in Arden hills. I know it is for the team and the team comes first but here is what I assume. If he could build up that unincorporated land with commercial and residential real estate he is pretty set on becoming a very richer man. Even if he sold the team or and built up the area the guy would have himself and family fortune for generations to come. This guy is a very smart Real estate Investor and holder from what I here. If you get the stadium out side of Minneapolis and build it up the surrounding 600 hundred acre lot your going to provide many different services that were downtown now going to Ziggy and other parties involved. Minnesota does not want this they want the stadium downtown so they can keep their current economic benefit. This is the real reason I think Arden hill wont be done with public financing or a vote from the legislature.
If it doesn’t work out for Ziggy and he want to sell the team I just hope the next owner keeps knockin at the capitols door for a stadium with out relocation.I know they need a stadium but if the wilfs cant make it happen don’t schedule the mayflower trucks for a midnight run just sell the team to another owner who will see if it can get done.
I think the NFL also is a huge factor in this. They don’t want to subsidize Minnesota so they are probably very influential towards these matter.
Everything I spoke of just be known was just my opinionated view. GO Vikes and get it done where you belong.
I hate to break it to you
But if Zygi can’t get a new stadium and get the financial backing he needs on it, then no one else will buy the team AND keep them in MN. No one’s going to buy a team that has been begging for 10 years with a really good owner for most of those years for a new stadium and not only denied, but thrown through hoops the whole time, only to get denied. It’s very simple, if the Vikings don’t get a stadium deal done this winter, they are gone. That is what all us fans need to be prepared for and what the MN Reps need to realize.
White Horn Gold Pants
WOW Rough day at the office.
Didn’t you guys here how many senators or legislators oppose just about everything my god. Do they want this team or not. Do guys understand how long it is going to take now to get any finance proposal solved after watching the hole session today wow.
There was a part that dealing with Indian casino or casinos could take uo to 18 months of litigation. I don;t quit remeber which discussion that was but I seems like a road block every turn. When the gentleman came in with the plan about the growth of Racinos and how much money they make one of the politicians was riding this guy hard totally disagreeing. The politician I think said he has been watching the racing events for about 20 years or following it the Racinos head figure said he has been doing it for around the same time.
There was so much testimony I can;t remember all involves so I am just making generalized referenced names.
I think I could get on board with this
my main concern is no public money, but a private casino to pay it off…until the details become clear, I have no problem.
Let's look at the politics of this
There are a variety of political objections to getting a stadium done, and this addressed many of them:
1. No public money for stadiums – Potentially addressed. The John Marty’s of the world (I’m assuming here, so maybe this isn’t fair) might still say that a casino that generates money for the state is still public money, but there political case is a lot harder. Nonetheless, there will still be some elected officials who take this line to say no, but this likely reduces the group’s size.
2. No expanded gambling (i.e., Chris’s "think of the children) – It’s hard to tell what’s behind the anti-gambling crowd’s objections. Some of it is related to the influence of the gaming lobby (addressed below), but some of it is actual moral objection to more gambling, often coupled with convenient beliefs about the dangers of relying on inconsistent gaming revenues or about the fungibility of fixed entertainment spending. Regardless, this group is not appeased here. I just don’t know how large it is, when they are separated from the Indian gaming exclusivity.
3. Indian gaming exclusivity — Anyone objecting on this ground should be fully appeased, assuming that the tribes who operate competing facilities are appeased. I don’t understand it enough to know for sure, but at least this proposal addresses the concern.
4. Local interest in Arden Hills/St. Paul – Addressed. Ramsey County and Arden Hills get the development they want, and some extra with a casino. Assuming they want a casino.
5. No new taxes – Potentially addressed. Those who have made tax pledges can say with a straight face that they didn’t raise taxes to build a stadium. They will still have to face charges that the casino revenue is a form of tax, of among the most regressive kind, but I suspect that message isn’t going to have too much effect on their constituents.
6. Local interest in Minneapolis — Not addressed.
But it sure seems to me like it could be tweaked to bring this one in. (Hold on folks, you aren’t going to like this). Arden Hills wants new development and tax base. So does Ramsey County. To do that, they want a stadium to anchor the development. Zyggi wants the same thing, to use the stadium as an anchor to build developments around. But doesn’t a casino do the same thing? It’s fewer people at a time, but it way more consistent traffic. Why aren’t the local interest in Ramsey County adequately served by just putting in the casino? And Zyggi could still make money developing the surrounding land.
Meanwhile, there is no reason a stadium and casino have to be adjacent (heck, the NFL might even prefer is they weren’t). So why not build the stadium downtown? Doing it that way gives everyone a big part of what they want, although not exactly what anyone wants. And heck, with the Strib land and the Armory, Zyggi can add some downtown development to profit from too.
Anyway, this Ojibwa proposal as is pays attention a broader basket of political concerns than anything that’s been proposed so far. That’s encouraging.
Casino and Stadium need to be adjacent for business purposes
“Meanwhile, there is no reason a stadium and casino have to be adjacent "
Not true. Ask youself – “why are the Indians willing to use money from a new casino to pay for the stadium?” If your answer is “they’re kind and generous souls that want to give back to the community”, you’d be wrong. Dead wrong.
The reason the tribe is willing to contribute to the cost of the stadium is because proximity to the stadium will drive additional business for the casino. The tribe wants to invest money, not give it away. Investments must have a return. What’s the return on the investment for the tribe? Driving traffic into the casino. That doesn’t happen if the casino is in Arden Hills and the stadium is downtown.
Just to clarify....
I’m not saying the White Earth Ojibwa aren’t kind and generous souls. Just saying that kindness and generosity are not the motivation behind the offer to pay for part of the stadium.
Actually
They are willing to do it because (1) they would get the closest-in casino site in the metro area, (2) they will only do it if Indian gaming exclusivity is extended, (3) doing so prevents Racino and a Block E casino, thus saving them a lot of money at other casinos across the state. That’s their return on investment.
I don’t think the stadium matters much to them at all. It’s ten dates a year of big crowds. That’s not enough to make them profitable. They need (and know they will get) regular traffic all by themselves, not to mention with Wilf’s other development plans.
Maybe missing those ten dates would cause them to want to reduce their contribution some, but that can be worked out.
Does the state have to approve a new casino?
This is a great option, but if the state government has to approve any new gambling facilities, then the fact that the Minneapolis Mafia has their claws deep up the you-know-whats of the state goverment is still going to be problematic.
I think so, yes
And that’s another reason why tweaking it makes sense to me.
There is another element...
This proposal puts forth an estimated $300 million in earnings per year. White Earth said they would give 50% of the profits to the MN government. First for paying off the stadium, then the state will CONTINUE to get money from the casino to use as they see fit.
This has WIN-WIN written all over it. So of course it will be completely ignored or all the tribes close to the Metro will oppose it.
Forgot
Here is a link to a story that contains the details…
http://minnesota.publicradio.org/collections/special/columns/polinaut/archive/2011/12/post_1.shtml
Not so fast...
This sounds like a great idea, but I’m not sure we want to get involved with this group. I know someone from Mahnomen and they didn’t have many good things to say about the tribe and how they go about business. The White Earth Tribe is also known for having crooked leaders. Check out a few supporting articles:
Property Taxes
Wadena
$18M Judgement
WR, CB, K & P of the Minnesota Machine
For those who think that casinos create portals to the Netherworld:
I can say you’re right. The Seminole Hard Rock Casino just outside of Tampa is a nightmare and has ruined the city.
Oh wait, no, the opposite. It’s actually a really great place that I hang out at sometimes even though I don’t gamble. And it has brought absolutely no extra crime or anything.
Never mind.
Dear Offensive Line... (follow Game Threads for the rest).
Follow @KJSegall
Ask someone that works at the local gamblers ananomous call center.
If the casino has helped the city.
It might be a the only way to finance a stadium that can pass the legislature but lets not go in eyes wide shut and cocky/smartassy about expanding gambling. It’s a serious matter to serious people.
by fanslaststand on Dec 7, 2011 5:42 PM CST up reply actions
I was in that area for a week on business
and went through many “bad” parts of town, but the casino area was never a safety concern.
indian casino.
I’ve said all along that we should talk with the Mystic Lake Casino and work with them to build a stadium back down in the southern suburbs where the Vikings started. Anywhere around the casino would do Bloomington, Eden Prairie. Shakopee, Savage, Burnsville or Eagan are all areas with roadways already that are better for traffic in and out of games especially compared to downtown Mpls. All kinds of restaurants motels and the Mall Of America (which the stadium is now named after). People coming to the game, in state or from out of state, would more likely STAY OVER NIGHT and spend more money for the FULL football and MINNESOTA experience. This is why Zygi has been pushing the suburbs for years, ex: Blaine, so he can build a shopping center/ motel complex to be the next Mall of America. Thats where his family will make their money.
Oh joy
The true Minnesota experience of shopping malls, chain restaurants and chain hotels. All with easier SUV access! Wow. That’s amazingly depressing.
But you might be right. That might be a truer Minnesota experience than things like the outdoors, the lakes, the Mississippi, St. Anthony Falls, theaters, quality restaurants, and the history of the milling that built the Twin Cities.
Did I mention that this is depressing?
by amiller92 on Dec 7, 2011 5:08 PM CST up reply actions 2 recs

by 




















