How Will The Minnesota Vikings' Triumvirate Fare?
As we all know, the Minnesota Vikings, outside the ownership and direction of Zygi and Mark Wilf, have largely been run by a three-headed committee: Brad Childress, Rick Spielman, and Rob Brzezinski. Unlike most other teams, there is no actual GM (although many see Spielman at times as such, he doesn't actually hold the title or in fact the authority that comes with it), and the three are given their respective positions and powers and expected to work together towards the goal of the betterment of the team.
And of course, there's been a change- Leslie Frazier as the new head coach and the new third of this chimera-style leadership, replacing Brad Childress. Another significant change of note is that Frazier does not have the full power that Childress had over the 53-man roster: most likely a result of some regret on Zygi Wilf's part stemming from the whole Randy Moss fiasco.
While at times this complex manner of running things seemed to work just fine, there were obviously a lot of bumps in the road- and for every 'incident' the public and media were aware of, it's probably safe to say there were three we didn't. These difficulties became especially exacerbated during last season, highlighted in particular again by Mossaggedon.
So, with a positional change in the leadership, but the structure remaining essentially otherwise the same, how will the Vikings fare in the future under this system? Let's explore after the jump.
Let's begin by remembering a fundamental rule of the NFL- championships are built from the top down. Make no bones about it, there's a reason the Redskins under Dan Snyder look nothing like the Steelers under the Ronneys. And while I would give a full vote of confidence behind both Zygi and Mark Wilf, there will be a lot of effects felt from how well the leadership of Frazier-Brzezinski-Spielman works out.
Let's begin by first briefly breaking down each person, regarding their personalities, experience, and jobs in this leadership.
Leslie Frazier- The most ‘unknown' in this group. As Head Coach, he seems to have been given free reign over building the coaching staff, and while they are an untested group, so far things look good. As mentioned above, Frazier does not have the authority over the roster that Childress did. Who exactly does, or if in fact that is now in the hands of the Wilfs, remains unknown. Frazier is also the least experienced in this group regarding his position. His tenure as interim head coach was successful enough that, considering the various disasters and tough situations that were thrown onto his plate, he landed himself the full-time job a day after the season ended. (It's also worth noting that he seemed to have the full confidence of the locker room throughout.) As a former defensive coordinator he's most likely to delegate authority in the offensive department, but again that remains an unknown, as offensive coordinator Darrell Bevell was an early casualty of coaching staff changes. His personality seems, at least through his media appearances and the words of those around him, to be a ‘tough-but-fair' type who has no problem working with others- a significant change from Childress' renowned ‘authoritarian' style. His role in the leadership again seems to be control over the coaching staff as well as the plays on the field. How much say he will have in player acquisitions is a bit of an unknown, but it would be extremely unreasonable to believe he won't have at least some say in that.
Rick Spielman- Despite recently suffering some embarrassment at the hands eyes of Scott Studwell, Spielman remains an extremely important part of this leadership. Again, while he is often seen as a de facto GM, his technical title is Vice President of Player Personnel. A former scout, he has largely had the authority and responsibility of acquiring players, both through FA and the draft. This caused some head-butting with former head coach Brad Childress, most notably with the acquisition/ release of Sage Rosenfals and Randy Moss. It should be noted that, with one person in charge of player acquisition and another person in charge of the final roster, these kind of clashes were practically predestined. His role does not seem to have changed with the Childress-Frazier transition, and how much role Frazier will have compared to him in future roster changes remains to be seen. As a side note, Spielman is apparently an absolutely awesome human being- he and his wife have adopted six children.
Rob Brzezinski- Despite being relatively ‘in the shadows' when the triumvirate is discussed, Brzezinski has the quite crucial role of Vice President of Football Operations, in which he has the duty and authority to negotiate contracts for the players and keep the Minnesota Vikings under the salary cap. This means that Leslie Frazier can suggest a player he wants and Rick Spielman can go about getting him- but if Rob Brzezinski and that player/agent can't come to terms, tough luck. While this kind of potential problem hasn't ever manifested itself, there's no denying the possibility, as well as the further chance that it has happened and we simply haven't heard about it. For example- Spielman might have acquired Randy Moss, and Childress might have waived him- but it's entirely possible Brzezinski is the reason Moss was never signed to a long term contract right off the bat regardless. So when we are all discussing the contract situations regarding players such as Sydney Rice, Ray Edwards, Chad Greenway, and Adrian Peterson- keep in mind that at that point, it's in Brzezinski's hands.
So there are your three fearless leaders, in their own nutshells. Again, the big dynamic behind all of this is the fact that for our beloved Vikings to succeed, these three individuals must first be able to successfully work together. The amount of pain suffered by the Vikings during the 2010 season was, at times, partly due to when this relationship broke down. It seemed, by all accounts, that Spielman and Childress were more often engaging in power struggles rather than cooperation. Whether the blame rests largely with Childress, or whether it's just easier to make the former head coach a scapegoat, remains to be seen. In a joint interview Monday during the combine in Indianapolis, Frazier and Spielman seemed to be getting along and did not appear to foresee any problems. A quote from Judd Zulgad on the joint decision making regarding the roster reads:
"Frazier acknowledges that when it comes to the draft, Spielman and his scouts have very good knowledge of players, and thus he wouldn't have a problem going with their recommendation should there be a difference of opinion. Spielman, meanwhile, knows the importance of getting the coaches' input and not forcing a player on them."
Sounds good, but let's keep the perspective that this was a media interview- the two won't go for each other's throats with cameras flashing, at least not this early in the game.
Let's just hope for the sake of our beloved Vikings that this Triumvirate can keep the good vibes flowing behind the scenes as well as in front of the press. Should there be another power struggle again, then we're going to see a repeat of some of the headaches of 2010- and, hopefully, a complete overhaul of this current power structure set up by the Wilfs. This is the second chance the ‘rule by committee' theory is being tried out; if it fails again, there shouldn't be a third.
15 comments
|
0 recs |
Do you like this story?
Comments
Scott Studwell disagrees on who's in the TOA
and will maim you if you don’t include him in future articles.
"Boom, winning." --Charlie Sheen, modern day Renaissance Man.
Bring him on!
I just cut a deal where Bryant McKinnie will be my bodygu… wait, where’d McKinnie go?
…
Oh crap.
Hail the Minnesota Vikings, ye mortals.
All other NFL fans are heretics.
www.dailynorseman.com- THE place for true Viking fanatics.
haha, Scott's eyes
now that Chilly is gone, Spielman can do more of what he does without a lot of impediment. I’m excited for this years draft because Spielman really knows what he is doing, and i know what ever player we do end up choosing is going to work out. (i have to be optimistic)
How do you know what Spielman has done and what Chilly did? Was it Spielman that drafted Thigpen and Booty? Who decided Tyrell Johnson was the world’s next best safety? Which one decided to wait till the 5th round last year before selecting an O-Lineman.
Right now this teams future hangs on many late round draft picks development.
Jaymar Johnson, Brian Robison, LeRoy Guion, Jon Sullivan, Jasper Brinkley, and Chris DeGeare.
If these players are the real deal we will be singing the praises of Spielman/Childress in the future. If they don’t work out the team can be vilified. But to select one of them as a bad guy isn’t fair. I will remind everyone that Chilly was granted an extension because All was Well with the Vikings not to awfully long ago.
IT IS TIME TO DO WHAT IT TAKES TO DRAFT A FRANCHISE QUARTERBACK.
No more old guys. No more excuses. No more passing up our own great drafted quarterback.
This is a very valid point.
It’s easiest- and perhaps the most optimistic thing to do- to just make Childress the scapegoat, because he was unpopular, and also because he’s gone and Spielman’s still here. But we really have no idea what the dynamics of that were. For all we know, Spielman ended up hating Childress’ guts and went out of his way with certain moves just to tick him off. As I wrote above though, one thing was certain- having one guy in charge of acquistions and one guy in charge of the 53 man roster was bound to cause some problems.
In that light, the Childress-Frazier change has seen, in a sense, a bit of a boost in Spielman’s authority. Frazier no longer can just cut any player Spielman gets at will. Again, what exactly that process entails now- I don’t know. I imagine it’s some sort of group consensus that’s brought before the Wilfs. In which case, we might be set up for another potential power struggle.
Hail the Minnesota Vikings, ye mortals.
All other NFL fans are heretics.
www.dailynorseman.com- THE place for true Viking fanatics.
Though I normally like the guy
I will forever blame Spielman for last years draft. Which in my books goes down as the worst Vikings draft in recent memory. The bad decisions were abundant and atrocious.
If last years draft was the worst
What does that make the 2005 draft then?
This draft certainly wasn’t worst but I will agree that it was not very good either. I think we got a solid guy in Toby But the jury is still out on Cook.
Who said life was fair?
When I find that person I'll beat the hell out of him
I agree.
It wasn’t a great draft, but it wasn’t the worst, either. I do think Gerhart has got a future with us. I still see him as a downgrade from Taylor, but let’s admit it- Taylor was getting a bit long in the tooth for a RB, and maybe Gerhart can be coached into that position. The only question remains- was he worth the big jump up to get him?
As far as Chris Cook, I’ll hold out some hope, but I’m worried about those two back-to-back injuries in his first season. Granted, one knee injury typically leads to increased stress on the other- those kind of situations are far from uncommon. But it wasn’t exactly an auspicious start.
Hail the Minnesota Vikings, ye mortals.
All other NFL fans are heretics.
www.dailynorseman.com- THE place for true Viking fanatics.
I still maintain that the jury is out on the 2010 draft .
Everyone villifies it because we didn’t draft a rookie of the year. But we did get the best CB available ( rated 6th in the draft). The move for Toby was planned when we moved out of the 1st round. We obtained a possible starter as a DE in the 4th. We already have seen flashes of good things from DeGeare. Many think Webb might be our starting QB.
Our 5th round TE is playing for Miami.
All of that in a draft where you had no 1st or third round choice.
To many people are jumping the gun on this one.
IT IS TIME TO DO WHAT IT TAKES TO DRAFT A FRANCHISE QUARTERBACK.
No more old guys. No more excuses. No more passing up our own great drafted quarterback.
by lifelongvike on Mar 4, 2011 11:11 PM CST up reply actions
In fairness the 2005 draft was before the TOA started running things
But yeah, it was a terrible, terrible draft. And I think Cook will be okay if he can stay healthy. Sure he struggled, but he looked really good at times. I think he’ll be all right.
"Boom, winning." --Charlie Sheen, modern day Renaissance Man.
He'd better
for that tender we placed on him.
Hail the Minnesota Vikings, ye mortals.
All other NFL fans are heretics.
www.dailynorseman.com- THE place for true Viking fanatics.
What tender?
IT IS TIME TO DO WHAT IT TAKES TO DRAFT A FRANCHISE QUARTERBACK.
No more old guys. No more excuses. No more passing up our own great drafted quarterback.
by lifelongvike on Mar 4, 2011 11:12 PM CST up reply actions
Bleh.
Sorry, had a brain fart and confused which Cook we were talking about. I was talking about Ryan Cook- obviously, wrong player.
Hail the Minnesota Vikings, ye mortals.
All other NFL fans are heretics.
www.dailynorseman.com- THE place for true Viking fanatics.
Did you not think we should keep Ryan Cook?
I find him versatile and a good back-up.
IT IS TIME TO DO WHAT IT TAKES TO DRAFT A FRANCHISE QUARTERBACK.
No more old guys. No more excuses. No more passing up our own great drafted quarterback.
By no means.
I absolutely agree that Cook was worth keeping. That said, 1.96 million- mind you, for just one year- is quite the price tag. I just hope he earns it.
Hail the Minnesota Vikings, ye mortals.
All other NFL fans are heretics.
www.dailynorseman.com- THE place for true Viking fanatics.

by 
























