Minnesota Vikings' Worst Draft Pick Ever - Dimitrius Underwood
In the history of the NFL Draft, there have been successes, and there have been busts. . .good picks, bad picks, and every sort of pick in between. However, in the history of the NFL Draft, there are few picks that could be labeled with such terminology as "blindly stupid" or "willfully ignorant."
The Minnesota Vikings made such a selection on April 17, 1999, in the first round of the 1999 NFL Draft.
Ladies and gentlemen, I give you Dimitrius Underwood. . .the runaway winner for the title of the worst draft pick in the history of the Minnesota Vikings' franchise.
The Vikings had the 29th pick in the first round of the 1999 NFL Draft. . .that one they earned on their own. However, they also acquired the 11th overall selection in that draft as well, because they dealt quarterback Brad Johnson to the Washington Redskins in exchange for a first and third round pick in the 1999 Draft and a second round pick in the 2000 Draft. The Vikings drafted Central Florida's Daunte Culpepper with the 11th pick, and many people figured that they would take a defensive player with their 29th pick.
Denny Green. . .again, he of the marvelous defensive talent evaluation skills. . .did, indeed, take a defensive player with the 29th pick. However, rather than a player that had been projected at around that spot, Green made a massive reach for a player that was graded at somewhere between Round Five and Round Seven. . .and, according to his own college coach, may not have been worthy of being drafted at all.
That's right. . .Dimitrius Underwood's own college coach at Michigan State, Nick Saban, had told numerous National Football League teams that Underwood did not have the mental acuity to make it in the National Football League. He had missed the entire 1998 season because of an ankle injury. . .an injury that, according to some accounts, he spent the entire year faking.
Apparently, Denny Green was not one of the NFL muckety mucks that received that memo, because he took Underwood with a first round selection. He referred to Underwood as a "bonus pick," which exhibited either a supreme confidence or an unbelievable arrogance.
Hey, it was Denny Green. . .which direction would you lean on that one?
And so it was that the Vikings selected Underwood, and signed him to a contract. Now, throughout the course of this list, we've talked about players that didn't step on the field for the Vikings and all that. But, in the case of Underwood, forget making it onto the field for an actual game. . .
Dimitrius Underwood didn't even make it through his first training camp practice. Yes, to borrow Allen Iverson's words. . .we talkin' 'bout PRACTICE.
Practice.
Underwood signed a five-year, $5.3 million deal with the Vikings on August 1, 1999. The Vikings' first training camp practice was on August 2, 1999. After practice, he left the Vikings' team facility, hitched a ride to the Minneapolis-St. Paul Airport, and was found in Philadelphia four days later with eight dollars and change in his pockets. He told the people that found him that he was torn between football and Christian ministry.
In the end, Underwood agreed to return his signing bonus money to the team, and the Vikings cut him. At the time, he said he was retiring from football, but "un-retired" two weeks later to sign a one-year, $395,000 contract with the Miami Dolphins. A month after that, he went from Miami to Lansing, Michigan, got into an argument with the mother of his children, cut himself on the throat, and was found walking down the road, bleeding profusely.
Maybe being drafted in the first round is what triggered Dimitrius Underwood to go through the mental roller coaster he went through. . .maybe it would have happened had be been drafted late in the draft or if he had not been drafted at all. Perhaps it was fear of failure that made Underwood react the way that he did.
Whatever the reason was, the perfect storm of circumstances that conspired to make the entire string of events occur make Dimitrius Underwood the single worst draft pick in the history of the Minnesota Vikings.
Are You Smarter Than The Experts?
Correctly predict the first 32 picks of the 2011 NFL Draft and you’ll win $10,000,000!
BEST ROUND EVER IN PRIMETIME
Enter at facebook.com/BudLight
Here We Go
Enjoy Responsibly ©2011 Anheuser-Busch, Inc., Bud Light® Beer, St. Louis, MO. ©2011 NFL Properties LLC. All NFL-related trademarks are trademarks of the National Football League. No Purchase Necessary. Contest open to U.S. residents (except CA) 21+. Contest begins 12AM CDT on 4/1 and ends 5:59:59PM CDT on 4/28. See Official Rules for complete details. Void where prohibited.
20 comments
|
1 recs |
Do you like this story?
Comments
bad but the worst???
he’s bad but the worst???
It’s got to be a tie. Erasmus James and Troy Williamson and without the other they might not be a sure lock. Mistakes happen but to have two first rounders in one year turn up like they did. Last I heard Troy Williamson couldn’t catch a bus and Erasmus James ended up…well???
Underwood was a 29th pick too, not a top 20 pick and therefore doesn’t deserve the title. Speaking of 29 I’m only 29 so my opinion only dates back thus far…
my 2 cents…
Erasmus James was the worst IMO
"Wes [Johnson] is old, passive, and below-average in every aspect of his game except outside shooting and smiling" - PoorDick
Worst!
Erasmus and Troy at least made the field and played [or at least attempted to]. Just think, there is a lot of bemoaning going on over Brad Childress singlehandedly throwing away this year’s third round choice when he summarily fired Randy Moss less than month into his return as a Viking. That was a third round choice. Dimitrius was the ultimate waste a first rounder. First rounders are expected to play and in most instances start, not just be a whiff of air left in an empty locker.
It may take a village to raise a child, but it takes a Viking to raze a village.
29th vs. a 7th
I think Williamson was the worst. The fact that he was on the field had more to do with where he was picked in the draft than his ability. No coach wants to admit that the 7th overall pick shouldn’t be on the field. Dimitrius Underwood was a very, very troubled guy. Erasmus James had very, very bad knees. Troy Williamson had very, very bad hands. They all ended up being busts, but at number 7, Troy Williamson was by far the biggest bust.
But he played, and he caught some TD's
he didn’t catch as many as we thought he would, but we got ZERO production out of the 29th pick. A lot of good players can be drafted 29+ overall.
Really, People?
Sorry, but even though James and Williamson were obvious busts, at least they contributed something. And while expectations may have been over-inflated for them, they at least tried, and at the time, they weren’t considered “reaches”. The picks were only stupid in retrospect.
The pick of Dimitrius Driftwood (my preferred name for him) was a mind-bogglingly stupid move from the moment his name was announced. And he lived up to the billing. When a guy can’t even make it through one practice before giving up, that’s not going to be topped. James and Williamson, bad though they were, aren’t even in the same area code with this guy.
by TheQatarian on Apr 16, 2011 11:49 AM CDT reply actions 4 recs
My feelings EXACTLY
That’s a rec.
"Lord I pray for the eyes of an eagle, the heart of a lion and the balls of a combat helicopter pilot."
Yep nailed this one,
I’ve been waiting all along for them to do this guy. He’s such a disaster, google him sometime it’s almost funny except it’s so awful.
It's a lot easier to love the Vikings when they win...
denny green mad such a terrible decision, cuz he was drinking BUD L!GHT.
in the future there will be no war...there will only be rollerball.
2 cases a day!!!
Dimitrius Underwear is not who I thought he was!! So crown my ass!!
by Bodysuit Man on Apr 16, 2011 5:47 PM CDT up reply actions
Underwood was a bad pick no doubt
But there were a few players on this list that never played for the Vikes. WIlliamson is the worst pick in my mind because was taken so high. For me its all about how high they were taken.
"I am patient with stupidity but not with those who are proud of it."
You obviously don't understand ROI
Look it up. it’s called Return On Investment. We actually got SOMETHING from Williamson, despite he did not live up to a 7th overall reputation, we got absolutely NOTHING for Underwear. NOTHING.
29th pick overall is an expected starter, and in many cases can be a huge stud. Where was Clay Matthews taken a few years ago? Wasn’t Aaron Rodgers taken like 30th one year? Many second round picks turn into awesome players.
Do you watch football? Do you understand the concept of production?
Take it easy there Troy
Its just my opinion. Sure you had some speed and yes you probably would have done everyone a big favor if you had punched out Chilly after he sent you packing, but you simply could not catch. And while I may or may not watch as much football as you, I do know that the main duty for a receiver is to catch the freakin ball. That drop in Denver was the nail in the coffin for you. Sorry bud as someone else so eloquently stated earlier, you couldn’t catch an STD going bareback in a Vietnamese whorehouse. Or was it a Korean whorehouse? Well you get the point. Or maybe you dont. Oh well. Take care Troy.
"I am patient with stupidity but not with those who are proud of it."
ROI
Troy Williamson cost the Vikings $12.1M over 3 years. Underwood cost the Vikings nothing. So from a financial perspective, Williamson was a much worse investment than Underwood.
From an expected draft value perspective, Williamson was a number 7 pick (1500 points). Underwood at pick 29 represented 640. You could have picked 2.3 Underwood’s to get the level of draft suckiness that the Vikings got with Williamson at number 7.
And from another perspective, Williamson was a far worse pick because he not only was terrible, but he took up space on the field. Underwood clearly didn’t take up space, so others could fill his shoes (e.g. Duane Clemons with 9 sacks in the 1999 season). The only stat of this kind I have about Williamson is that he caught 37 receptions in 2006 and had 11 drops. His drops tended to be killers (e.g. his two drops in Denver in the 2007 season). Underwood was a terrible pick because he never got on the field. Williamson was a terrible pick, because he was terrible when he was on the field. I’d take the former over the latter, particularly when using the 29th pick versus the 7th to get those results.

by 

























