Super Bowl 2006
Referee Bill Leavy once apologized for blowing several calls in Super Bowl XL that may have cost the Seahawks a chance to win a championship. On Sunday in San Francisco, Leavy and his crew bungled a call in the second quarter that gave the 49ers an extra down against the Packers. A play later, the 49ers scored a touchdown, and went on to win 34-28
Referee Bill Leavy and his officiating crew may want to brush up on the NFL rulebook before Week 4. For the second time in three week's, Leavy's crew made an errant call in a game.
During the second quarter of Sunday's game between Cleveland and Minnesota, Browns punt returner Travis Benjamin muffed a punt that Vikings linebacker Larry Dean picked up and returned for a touchdown. However, under NFL rules, muffed punts can't be advanced, so the officials correctly ruled that it would be Vikings ball at Cleveland's 26-yard line.
That's when things went awry. Vikings coach Leslie Frazier challenged the call, hoping for a touchdown. However, coaches aren't allowed to challenge plays that are automatically reviewed, such as turnovers and touchdowns.
In 2012, the penalty for wrongly challenging a play was a 15-yard unsportsmanlike conduct flag. Lions coach Jim Schwartz was famously hit with this flag in a Thanksgiving game that Detroit ended up losing to Houston in overtime.
However, the NFL changed the rule after the 2012 season so that a team wouldn't be penalized 15 yards. Instead, a team would just be charged a timeout. So the Vikings should have been charged a timeout, but that didn't happen.
"It turned out to be a muff, which you can't review," Frazier said, via the Associated Press. "Should've been a timeout (taken away), but they walked off 15. Not sure why. But I can't throw the red flag in that situation."
The 15-yard penalty was enforced by Leavy's crew and instead of having the ball first-and-10 at the Cleveland 26, Minnesota was given the ball at the Cleveland 41-yard line, facing a first-and-25.
"A timeout should have been charged instead of a 15-yard penalty," Leavy told a pool reporter after the game.
"The ruling on the field was that there was no possession by the receiving player," Leavy said. "Therefore, it was a muffed kick and could not be advanced by the kicking team."
The Vikings ended up getting a field goal on the drive, but being 15-yards closer could have made a world of difference because a touchdown would've meant the Vikings finished with four more points in a game they lost by four points.
Leavy's crew is the same crew that was downgraded after the officiating fiasco that occurred in San Francisco in Week 1. In that game, the NFL acknowledged that Leavy's crew made two incorrect calls.
The Vikings sucked it up.... but this official needs to look at the rulebook.
But before this is over I just want to show what would have happened had Ponder not been our QB.
Hmm, can't get it to work (onto DN) but here's the link